Formaggio Pizzeria — Restaurant in Columbus

I found out about this place due to a hanging menu on my door last week. So I ordered takeout tonight and dropped by to pick it up. I’ll be honest, I didn’t really expect it to be connected to the gas station. But no worries, you can see into their whole kitchen and everything looked to be very clean and orderly, so don’t be dismayed by the curb appeal of the building. For some reason, my ticket hadn’t printed up to their kitchen so my food wasn’t ready when I got there. No problem though, the guys working apologized and got to work on my order. They were even kind enough to bring it out to my car so I could be comfortable and wait out there. It only took about ten minutes and was totally worth the wait. When I got home everything was hot, fresh, and delicious. You can tell it’s actually good quality cheese on the margherita pizza. The Stromboli was very good as well, but I think the pizza was the star here. I also got an order of wings which were very good. Great size and the hot sauce had a nice classic buffalo flavor.

I’ll definitely swing by again, as the food was great, priced well, and the guys working were also very hospitable. This is the kind of spot everyone on the west side...

I recently visited this restaurant and had a really great experience. The food was absolutely delicious — full of flavor, well-balanced, and clearly made with fresh ingredients.

The service was professional and efficient. The staff were friendly and attentive, which made the whole experience even more enjoyable. The place itself was clean and nicely set up, creating a relaxed and comfortable atmosphere. Overall, I had a very positive experience and would definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone who appreciates good food. I’m already looking forward to coming back and trying...

The wings are INCREDIBLE BOYS!! The Hot was delicious and not crazy spicy and the wings are fat and juicy!!! I would normally post a picture when the food is this good but we ate everything. Like we cleared house, everything is gone there's barely some bones left..

This place killed it! Service was AMAZING. I'm gluten intolerant so I'm super sensitive to wings. Waited till the next morning to make sure I didn't die.. lol NO problems whatsoever didn't ask for ANYTHING specific just ordered...