Pizza Man — Restaurant in Eagan

Best value in town!! This place has been our go-to for a long time. We’ve tried the others and do still every so often. We’re reminded each time of why we prefer Pizza Man. We do the carry out special on a family size pizza. The original thin crust is spot-on… thin but with just the right combination of moisture and simple, but delicious flavor. We also often get the thick crust (same price). They use two doughs. It’s amazing and a jumbo is enough for my wife and I and our 4 kids (all under 8). The price is $5-10 lower per equally-sized pizza than most others. Some places don’t even offer a 16”. The days-long process for making perfect dough that results in truly tasty dough & crust with the right consistency (no need to use an over abundance of cheap spices to mask an inferior dough like many others). Carefully selected cheese from a local dairy in Wisconsin which they hand-grate in store (it’s the best cheese in my opinion). The sauce - my kids actually really enjoy it, and they can be very picky eaters. This Pizza Man is is a humble-looking place with kind staff, and they dish out a simple fair, but they get it so right every time that it is truly gourmet.

They’re even cool enough (and confident enough in their skill) to sell me the cheese blocks and dough they use and share details on how they make their crust and pies. It’ll level-up your home pizzas for sure.

I’m amazed this place isn’t rated higher....

This used to be my favorite pizza place, until tonight. I order from Pizza Man frequently. The pizza that I received tonight had topping only on one side if the pizza and the rest was all the way at one end of the box. My order for pizza and garlic toast was $39.00 and I gave a $10 tip. Now you would think the driver or someone would say, "oh I'm sorry I dropped your pizza, we'll get you another one." Nope never said a word. Looking closer at the crust it was not even remotely round. I called in to complain and could barely understand the person that answered. He did sound very intoxicated. He said he was the night GM. He offered me a $10 credit. Nice. I told him I did not want a credit I was calling to let him know what happened. Great pizza most of the time, but something was very wrong at Pizza Man tonight. Unfortunate what is happening to this great...

Pizza left a lot to be desired for the price. It's a decent pizza, I just don't feel it's a good value.

My main gripe was it took a ridiculously long time for delivery. I was told 45 minutes and it was an hour and 15 I believe, which if I was told they were that busy I'd have picked it up. It would also be appreciated if you'd ask if I want peppers since the drivers don't seem to carry them.

If the service wasn't great it'd definitely be a two star, but the guy on the phone and delivery driver both offered good customer service, so thank you.

Edit. Now I'm just pissed off. I look in my statement today and that's a 42 dollar charge plus my 20...