Milk & Sugar Scoop Shoppe — Restaurant in Evansville

The day my husband and I went we were served by the owner's daughter. She was awesome. She took time to explain the story behind Milk and Sugar and how it got started. She was super friendly and polite. The inside decor of the place is modern farmhouse minimalism is I guess how I would describe it. The flavors of the ice cream are dreamy and heavenly. The flavors rotate. There are vegetarian, vegan and non dairy options as well. I tried some of the non dairy cookie dough and it was wonderful. I also had a double scoop waffle cone as did my husband and with tip and tax it came to about $16. Well worth it as the portion size was large and...

Overall I do like this ice cream shop but I have a couple small issues. the first is that there is no music and the shop is rather large so anything you say, even in a whisper gets echoed around and people can hear you. It feels like the second you walk in, all eyes are on you. Another is that the prices seem rather high. The ice cream is great so I'm willing to pay for it but compared to other ice cream shops in town, it seems high. Parking can also be an issue since it's located on Franklin Street and there's limited parking in front of the shop but not a...

Service was great. The only thing I found disappointing was that the cotton candy (and maybe all of the ice cream) was definitely not made by the creamery. Typically, I like to go to the smaller ice cream parlors because the assumption is that the ice cream is locally made.

Amex concierge did recommend this shop. And I think that it is worthy of the recommendation. I do think that there should be a little asterisk that says that it isn't locally made, though.

P.s. I don't literally mean there should be an asterisk. More of here's a review so...