Gary's Hometown Deli — Restaurant in Geneseo

Just had lunch there for the first time today. Good rueben, excellent loaded Mac & cheese, and I had no idea that one of the local breweries made soda, but they sell it there and that was the best orange cream soda I have ever tasted. My coworker and I went there having never been before, so we didn't call our order in ahead. We had a pretty large order and I don't think it took them ten minutes to serve us and have us on our way. All in all a great...

I give you a 4 star, because I think you have a wonderful deli, but when I drive 10 miles and find out your closed and your internet post says you're open I can tell you I won't be back for awhile. I will also tell you being a retired retail manager that having incorrect or inconsistent hours is a cancer on any business .so I would tell others to call before driving in don't go by what they have posted on...

Everytime I’ve been in, the service is impeccable and everyone always has a smile on their face. The potato salad is one of my absolute favorites and have been grabbing 1 qt almost every week for lunches. Recently had the pulled pork sandwich meal and got a premade salad to have with it and it was one of the best lunches in town I’ve had in a while. Highly recommend stopping in to see their...