Cold Stone Creamery — Restaurant in Grand Island

I went in to try a signature. Tried the Oreo Overload and it was extremely disappointing. It’s routine vanilla ice cream with a handful of very cheap mini chocolate chips and two single cream Oreos that were broken in half. Four bites had Oreo in it, most was plain vanilla and some had a couple mini chocolate chip. A scoop of routine cookie dough has more cookie content and is much cheaper. Disappointing Signature which is just vanilla. Service was adequate; very poor value, not...

Horrible--ice cream was fine; however, waffle bowl was stale, server seemed like she wanted to be elsewhere and we were imposing on her time, I got three strawberries - 3 - for my money I paid extra for, and then she didn't mix up my ice cream with my two add-ins at all. After spending all the money we did on two items, receiving so-so service and food, we won't...

“This is the first Cold Stone I’ve visited that completely lost the unique appeal the brand is known for. I’ve been to Cold Stone locations in 40 cities across 12 states, and every one of them consistently upheld the true Cold Stone experience—except this one. To the people of Grand Island, Nebraska, I’m sorry that your Cold Stone isn’t delivering the experience...