Jimmy John's — Restaurant in Greencastle

I have now been to this location 4 times in the past two weeks between the hours of 6-8 PM (normal dinner hours). Each time I was unable to be served because they were out of bread! FOUR TIMES!! One time, sure, but FOUR times at a small town location is unheard of. I literally went as a joke the other night cause I figured there was no way there would be no bread FOUR times. But yep either they are just messing with me or there is a national bread shortage I am unaware of. Also apparently you don’t have to wear masks at this Jimmy John’s cause only one out of the four workers had it on the last time I went so that’s good at least. I’m not even angry, honestly I find it kind of funny at this point that this Jimmy John’s continues to be open despite not having bread. People who work at this store are actually getting free money to just hangout and socialize and I’m all for it. I’ll keep going back to see how many times I can go before they can actually serve sandwiches. Will keep you all...

This particular location has had a slow start at the gate due to their popularity at launch. My original order (online and living only a mile away) took almost 20 minutes. Willing to give them another try though they got it down to less than 10 on most orders. Not having eaten there I can't say how it looks on property but being shoved next to a video store this is definitely a delivery based store. The food has never been been wrong and has not disappointed. Having eaten at several different locations I can comfortably say this is and hopefully will stay above average. Good luck to them and here is hoping they can stick around while staying strong. I know what I'm ordering next time I'm stuck...

Normally, I love this place. I’m always open to trying something new, so I can usually find a sandwich that I enjoy. Til tonight, and I actually chose a safe option, or so I thought, and ordered tuna, with all goodies. What I got was this…and I am sooo disappointed. My sandwich had barely sprinkling of lettuce and one tomato slice, I never did find my peppers or pickles or oregano or o&v.. and worst of all -the tuna was really really old or something like that. It was hard on the surface and discolored somewhat and the smell and flavor were just plain yuck. Every other time I’ve eaten here I’ve been very satisfied. But tonight I skipped dinner for fear of the repercussions! Live and...