Casey's — Restaurant in Jefferson

My kids love the pizza. We have done several orders so far and there have been zero issues. I have ordered via the app and each time, it's made and ready at the time I selected. The coupon deals have been great. The employees inside have been nice and friendly. The store and bathrooms have been clean the few times we have gone inside. Lots of products to pick from. Of course prices are a tad higher, but this is not a grocery store ;) Pricing is comparable to KT and other gas stations in the area. The app is a great way to save $$ and also can use your rewards and back to my kids schools. They have been a good supporter of our public schools in the area, we appreciate...

We ordered pizza for pick for my son’s birthday and when we got there to pick them up, they gave our pizzas to someone else and we left with no pizza and guest waiting for food. We ended up only having cake and will never shop there again!! This is not the first time for poor customer service ordering pizza. But it will be the last!!! Many other companies to give my business too. Corporate step up and fix this problem in Jefferson and Fort Atkinson stores.. your employees could care less to correct the mistakes or make the pizzas when ordering on line. Claim they never looked at the Order when you arrive to pick...

Every time I go into Casey's, it so happens Kyle is working. When i come here, which is later afternoons. He is always very friendly and kind. I've also ordered pizza here, and he is the one who usually makes it. He makes the BEST pizza! Just the right amount of toppings, the orders are always right, they are always hot and fresh. One of the best pizzas in town! I am so happy with his service, I had to give him...