HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

NewCity Coffee Co. — Restaurant in Lake Mary

Name
NewCity Coffee Co.
Description
Nearby attractions
WineART Wednesdays at Downtown Lake Mary
100 N Country Club Rd, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Nearby restaurants
4th Street Bar & Grill
132 N 4th St #1200, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Flippers Pizza - Lake Mary
120 N 4th St, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Krazy Greek Kitchen
142 W Lakeview Ave #1000, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Root's Raw Juice Bar
134 N 4th St STE 1220, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Dalli's Pizzeria
101 N Country Club Rd, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Lighthouse Seafood Market & Cafe
101 N Country Club Rd, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Rita’s Café: Books, Wine, & Language Exchange (formerly French Café 1515)
187 E Crystal Lake Ave #1021, Lake Mary, FL 32746
iPho Noodle House
3005 W Lake Mary Blvd #108, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Tijuana Flats
3005 W Lake Mary Blvd STE 109, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Beth's Burger Bar
223 Wheelhouse Ln #1121, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
NewCity Coffee Co. tourism.NewCity Coffee Co. hotels.NewCity Coffee Co. bed and breakfast. flights to NewCity Coffee Co..NewCity Coffee Co. attractions.NewCity Coffee Co. restaurants.NewCity Coffee Co. travel.NewCity Coffee Co. travel guide.NewCity Coffee Co. travel blog.NewCity Coffee Co. pictures.NewCity Coffee Co. photos.NewCity Coffee Co. travel tips.NewCity Coffee Co. maps.NewCity Coffee Co. things to do.
NewCity Coffee Co. things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
NewCity Coffee Co.
United StatesFloridaLake MaryNewCity Coffee Co.

Basic Info

NewCity Coffee Co.

124 N 4th St STE 1500, Lake Mary, FL 32746
4.0(342)
order
order
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

attractions: WineART Wednesdays at Downtown Lake Mary, restaurants: 4th Street Bar & Grill, Flippers Pizza - Lake Mary, Krazy Greek Kitchen, Root's Raw Juice Bar, Dalli's Pizzeria, Lighthouse Seafood Market & Cafe, Rita’s Café: Books, Wine, & Language Exchange (formerly French Café 1515), iPho Noodle House, Tijuana Flats, Beth's Burger Bar
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(407) 915-7075
Website
newcitycoffeeco.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Lake Mary
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Lake Mary
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Lake Mary
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
Newcity Breakfast Sandwich
dish
Breakfast Burrito
dish
French Toast
dish
Pb And Banana Toast
dish
Avocado Toast
dish
Caprese Toast
dish
The George Special
dish
Horchata Latte
dish
Cortado
dish
Macchiato
dish
Nutella Milkshake
dish
Hot Chocolate
dish
Iced Coffee
dish
Nitro Cold Brew
dish
Chocolate Croissant
dish
Almond Croissant
dish
Berry Scone

Reviews

Nearby attractions of NewCity Coffee Co.

WineART Wednesdays at Downtown Lake Mary

WineART Wednesdays at Downtown Lake Mary

WineART Wednesdays at Downtown Lake Mary

4.6

(15)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Things to do nearby

Kayak through Winter Park lakes in Florida
Kayak through Winter Park lakes in Florida
Fri, Dec 12 • 10:30 AM
Winter Park, Florida, 32789
View details
Spooky Cats Creepmas Pop-Up
Spooky Cats Creepmas Pop-Up
Thu, Dec 11 • 11:00 AM
893 Florida 436, Casselberry, FL 32707
View details
Free Tai Chi/Qi Gong  Every Thursday 9:30am  at Metro Health of Apopka
Free Tai Chi/Qi Gong Every Thursday 9:30am at Metro Health of Apopka
Thu, Dec 11 • 9:30 PM
701 South Orange Blossom Trail, Apopka, FL 32703
View details

Nearby restaurants of NewCity Coffee Co.

4th Street Bar & Grill

Flippers Pizza - Lake Mary

Krazy Greek Kitchen

Root's Raw Juice Bar

Dalli's Pizzeria

Lighthouse Seafood Market & Cafe

Rita’s Café: Books, Wine, & Language Exchange (formerly French Café 1515)

iPho Noodle House

Tijuana Flats

Beth's Burger Bar

4th Street Bar & Grill

4th Street Bar & Grill

4.4

(874)

Click for details
Flippers Pizza - Lake Mary

Flippers Pizza - Lake Mary

4.5

(659)

Click for details
Krazy Greek Kitchen

Krazy Greek Kitchen

4.5

(818)

$$

Closed
Click for details
Root's Raw Juice Bar

Root's Raw Juice Bar

4.6

(198)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Reviews of NewCity Coffee Co.

4.0
(342)
avatar
1.0
7y

I was very shocked and dismayed by the service I experienced. I truly hope the owner reads this because My Boyfriend and myself are sick from your food. I've been to the restroom today more times than I ever had before and my co-workers are taking notice as is my boss and let me tell you, I am MORTIFIED and SICK! We went for a brunch Sunday 4/22/18 12:00- 12:30 and ran through rain to sit shivering in your restaurant waiting forever for our food. BUT WAIT!this gets better- there were a total of 6 people dinning (ourselves included) and our food took a total of 32 minutes to get to us. Everyone else had their food and drinks sooooooooo why did it take 32 minutes for eggs and a burrito? An omelette with egg whites takes a max total of 7 min and the burrito once the eggs are cooked as well should tax a max! of 12-15 min NOT EVEN! I can make the meal we ordered in 15 min and it not have runny egg whites or under-cooked meats. So i ate an under-cooked fritatta ? I cut into with my fork after putting sriracha on it and clear runny egg white seeped out. I had taken two bites prior to noticing that so if i am sick with somonilla YOU WILL BE HEARING FROM ME WITH PREJUDICE! I had to wait 10 minutes for anyone to come and assist me and I had to go to the counter and wave at the Chef? and the young man serving came over Kind of apologize and refunded us. :( I didn't get to eat, we were moving that day and I had to do it all with a very queasy stomach! So in conclusion I walked out in tears after being so flustered and frustrated by the service and lack of food, I am now sick as a dog at work because I can't miss work, bills must be paid. And your food is in whole to blame as i didn't eat anything else the rest of the day! I hope everyone sees this and takes a beat and notice before dining here, I will say on a last positive note your chai latte was probably the only thing that got me through my day. AND I WILL NOT BE DINING HERE EVER AGAIN! Get your staff in order, as a hospitality professional I will be letting my network know to let their network know to avoid your establishment. It only takes...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
2y

I should have read these reviews before attempting to get coffee drinks from this place today. Yikes!

Went in to get a specialty seasonal drink, that comes in a cute glass Santa tumbler. First visit, and I won’t ever go back.

Parking was a nightmare. Strike one.

While standing in a long line, the gentleman turned around to me and my daughter and said it was going to be a “long wait” (I guess he’d been waiting a long while to say this to us), which was fine with us because I couldn’t find the drink on their menu that they had been advertising on their social. While still standing in line I go to their Insta to find the drink and it’s name only to see a post made two days prior of it being “Sold Out”, but it stated they placed another order for the tumblers and would be in, in a few days- seeing this was posted two days ago I decided to remain in line and ask a worker if they were available today. Big mistake. I let her spray the whipped cream from a can, the Walmart brand- Strike two- for an order of a flight of coffees and did not stop her before delivering them outside, until she was returning back inside to ask.

I have never been treated in such a hostile manner by a worker before. She barely stopped for me to ask, and quickly said no. I should have stopped there, but my daughter really wanted the drink/tumbler so I asked (like their post said to check and see) if she knew when they would be back in… I didn’t even fully get this out before she had left & returned to the back counter and yelled another no to me.

The gentleman in front of me let out a “woah!”, so I know I am not overreacting in what transpired by my two simple questions.

Truly disgusting behavior, but reading others reviews on here, I see that they have been met with the same.

Opted to go to Starbucks instead. Oh, and found the glass tumblers...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
7y

After reading some good reviews we decided to try this local place out in lieu of a chain coffeehouse. Big mistake! Young kid running the front who we found out “wasn’t even suppose to be working today” (not my fault) was completely clueless on customer service. We ordered our coffee and sat down. He began making our drinks then proceeded to take another order and go to the back immediately completely forgetting our drinks. After waiting 10 minutes and watching him eating in the back with another man I approached and asked where our drinks were. He had completely forgotten them he said and began to finish. I asked for new ones because the ones that were halfway made were clearly cold by now. The other dark haired gentleman who was cooking in the back came forward and was the rudest employee I have ever encountered. He said loudly SO IT HAPPENS GET OVER IT! I said what happens poor customer service? He said yea so what? At this point I was furious that I had come out of my way in the pouring rain to give my business to this local place when I could have literally went across the street to Starbucks. And no one cares to give me an ounce of good service. I asked for my money back and told them I would go elsewhere. The dark haired man said fine leave! While the young boy continued to say he just forgot and shouldn’t have even been working today. He did offer to make the drinks but at this point it was too late. As we were walking out he yells “enjoy your Starbucks.” What a complete joke of a coffee shop. I hope the owner sees this and can retrain her employees to treat people better. And my mocha at Starbucks is currently delicious and I received it in a friendly and...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next

Posts

Kaylie JoyyKaylie Joyy
I have been coming here for years and was always greeted so kindly by staff; as of recently things are awful, the staff is different and they are no longer friendly. The quality is hit or miss but I kept trying to give them the benefit of the doubt. I will most likely never come back to this establishment. The guy working the register was incredibly rude today, I asked for the same drink I get every single time. I get oatmilk and prefer my drink layered like a machiatto (as pictured) this has NEVER been an issue in the past and has been done everytime I have frequented this establishment. The guy told me I was wrong and told me it can’t be done that way with oatmilk (then how was it done the millions of other times I have come here is beyond me) the guy proceeded to argue with me and did not want to remake my drink correctly, a lady came over and started remaking my drink while also arguing with me and telling me I’m wrong and it’s not possible but then started to say they have a different oat milk now that can’t hold the weight of the espresso. That’s all they needed to say, was that it’s a different oat milk. Instead the customer service was thrown out the window and I was treated horribly and talked down too. I’m disgusted with lack of customer service and treatment. I was handed my drink and told “ See, it’s already blending, it’s heavier than the oat milk” But my drink is literally layered like I asked it to be and the espresso did not blend down.
MichaelMichael
Why doesn’t NewCity Coffee Co. have a higher rating? They definitely deserve it! We came in a little while ago and were so pleasantly surprised with the nice atmosphere of this coffee shop as well as the wide selection of unique coffee drinks and such! This is not your standard Starbucks coffee shop with pretty generic drinks - they have many Asian-inspired drinks and more! We ordered two different flights - a coffee flight as well as an energy drink flight. I’m not sure if these same exacts flights are still on the menu, but they are SO GOOD and entirely worth getting! Every energy drink was homemade and had really unique flavors and every coffee was extremely good (lavender, violet, peach, and horchata). I think we have a good understanding of what NewCity Coffee Co. has to offer as we tried 8 different drinks, and each and every one of them was very good. I would be happy to get a full-sized version of every one. I can’t wait to come back! Hopefully more unique coffee flights and energy drink flights come in the near future! What an awesome place! 😄
Gema Leonela LimongiGema Leonela Limongi
This was my second time visiting this place, and sadly, it’s the second time I’ve been disappointed. I decided to give it another chance because the location is great and the place itself looks nice, but the service is just terrible. The staff acts like they’re doing you a favor by serving you, very poor attitude and zero hospitality. We ordered something simple (eggs and a burger), and they told us it would take 30 minutes. We said okay, but it took even longer than that. When the food finally arrived, it looked and tasted like it was made without care rushed, cold energy, no love at all. The presentation didn’t match the high prices, and the overall experience felt disrespectful to customers. I also ordered a chai latte, and it was awful, the flavor was overly artificial. We left really disappointed. It’s sad to see such a nice-looking place with so much potential offering such a poor experience. It’s on me for giving it a second chance after a bad first visit, but unfortunately, nothing changed.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Lake Mary

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

I have been coming here for years and was always greeted so kindly by staff; as of recently things are awful, the staff is different and they are no longer friendly. The quality is hit or miss but I kept trying to give them the benefit of the doubt. I will most likely never come back to this establishment. The guy working the register was incredibly rude today, I asked for the same drink I get every single time. I get oatmilk and prefer my drink layered like a machiatto (as pictured) this has NEVER been an issue in the past and has been done everytime I have frequented this establishment. The guy told me I was wrong and told me it can’t be done that way with oatmilk (then how was it done the millions of other times I have come here is beyond me) the guy proceeded to argue with me and did not want to remake my drink correctly, a lady came over and started remaking my drink while also arguing with me and telling me I’m wrong and it’s not possible but then started to say they have a different oat milk now that can’t hold the weight of the espresso. That’s all they needed to say, was that it’s a different oat milk. Instead the customer service was thrown out the window and I was treated horribly and talked down too. I’m disgusted with lack of customer service and treatment. I was handed my drink and told “ See, it’s already blending, it’s heavier than the oat milk” But my drink is literally layered like I asked it to be and the espresso did not blend down.
Kaylie Joyy

Kaylie Joyy

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Lake Mary

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Why doesn’t NewCity Coffee Co. have a higher rating? They definitely deserve it! We came in a little while ago and were so pleasantly surprised with the nice atmosphere of this coffee shop as well as the wide selection of unique coffee drinks and such! This is not your standard Starbucks coffee shop with pretty generic drinks - they have many Asian-inspired drinks and more! We ordered two different flights - a coffee flight as well as an energy drink flight. I’m not sure if these same exacts flights are still on the menu, but they are SO GOOD and entirely worth getting! Every energy drink was homemade and had really unique flavors and every coffee was extremely good (lavender, violet, peach, and horchata). I think we have a good understanding of what NewCity Coffee Co. has to offer as we tried 8 different drinks, and each and every one of them was very good. I would be happy to get a full-sized version of every one. I can’t wait to come back! Hopefully more unique coffee flights and energy drink flights come in the near future! What an awesome place! 😄
Michael

Michael

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Lake Mary

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

This was my second time visiting this place, and sadly, it’s the second time I’ve been disappointed. I decided to give it another chance because the location is great and the place itself looks nice, but the service is just terrible. The staff acts like they’re doing you a favor by serving you, very poor attitude and zero hospitality. We ordered something simple (eggs and a burger), and they told us it would take 30 minutes. We said okay, but it took even longer than that. When the food finally arrived, it looked and tasted like it was made without care rushed, cold energy, no love at all. The presentation didn’t match the high prices, and the overall experience felt disrespectful to customers. I also ordered a chai latte, and it was awful, the flavor was overly artificial. We left really disappointed. It’s sad to see such a nice-looking place with so much potential offering such a poor experience. It’s on me for giving it a second chance after a bad first visit, but unfortunately, nothing changed.
Gema Leonela Limongi

Gema Leonela Limongi

See more posts
See more posts