Niyyah Coffee — Restaurant in McCordsville

Obsessed with This New Coffee Spot!

I’m absolutely in love with this new coffee shop that just opened near me! From the moment you walk in, you can feel the good vibes. The owner is incredibly warm and welcoming, and the entire staff is genuinely friendly. The kind of place where they remember your name and your order.

The barista is a total artist and makes the best coffee I’ve had in ages. Every cup is rich, smooth, and perfectly balanced. I also love that they let you customize everything, swap, add, or mix ingredients to create your own masterpiece. It’s coffee luxury at its finest.

My whole family has already been there multiple times, and they’ve only just opened. It’s quickly become our favorite spot for a cozy morning or an afternoon pick me up. Chic atmosphere, flawless drinks, and the sweetest people. What more...

Happy to see another coffee shop open in McCordsville! Niyyah has a wide selection of coffee, tea, and pastries. I ordered a medium hot banana latte and chose whole milk (they also offer oat and almond). The latte was milky and flavorful, but weaker than I expected. My friend got the pumpkin suga shook, which was nearly the color of milk. For a large latte, they only use two shots of espresso, so you’re paying more for milk rather than extra coffee, it felt a bit diluted and misleading.

The shop has ample seating and lots of natural light from the windows, making it a great spot to work. I think they could improve the espresso-to-milk ratios unless you prefer a very milky drink. I also tried the chicken empanada, which was extremely dry. I’ll try other pastries in the future, but I’d pass...

Recently visited this Niyyah Coffee in McCordsville and was blown away by the level of service. The staff took the time to ask about my preferences and crafted a drink perfectly tailored to my taste. It wasn’t just a standard order, it felt personal and carefully made, with attention to detail in both flavor and presentation. Beyond the coffee, the friendly and attentive service made the entire experience warm and welcoming. This place truly goes above and beyond to make each guest...