Club Tavern — Restaurant in Menasha

Club Tavern has the best fish in the area. I want to try more on the menu, but I literally can’t order anything but their blackened and broiled salmon because it is so good! I also recommend either their German potato salad, fresh made soup or a salad for a healthy option. I find that the potion size is very reasonable for the price and am generally wishing I had not actually ate the entire meal because I’m so stuffed.

We have gone to CT a few times and we’re trying to make it a bi-weekly date destination after moving to the area a year ago. Over that time I’ve noticed a few things… you have to get there early or you will have a much longer wait time, you may not get a seat, or they might already be out of what you want. If you plan on getting a to go order, you may be denied because it’s already too busy… again make sure you call in early!

With all that being said, if you get an opportunity to get a seat and your food is available, I recommend sticking around because it’s so, so, so good! Be ready to order when Kelly comes around, but in the meantime, grab a drink from the bartender. Be prepared to feel a buzz… their drinks are stiff and delicious. I recommend their brandy old...

One place we like to go to (until now) is Club Tavern in Menasha. Good food, decent prices and a nice selection of beer. We had a party of 6 there yesterday at 4pm for drinks and food. Pretty sure all of our bills came to about $150. Well Mary ordered a pint of Stella which is her go to beer when available. She thought the taste was off so we asked the bartender to give Mary a bottle of Bud Lite instead. When it came time to pay the bill I asked the bartender if he charged us for the Stella. He said of course cuz you ordered it and then didn't want it. He also said the Stella tasted fine to him. Someone in our group had a BIG problem with us being charged for that beer. It got to the point where the bartender actually said "if you don't like it...

We ordered grilled haddock and fried perch and they were both great. The sides for the fish dinner were also good, I liked that their cole slaw had a vinaigrette dressing which complemented the heavier fish dinner and other sides. The jalapenos that you can add to the American fries side add a lot of spice so don't add them if you can't tolerate spicy food well enough. We also heard a lot of compliments for the german potato salad side from others...