Attilio's Villagio Restaurant & Pizzeria — Restaurant in Middletown Township

Today the pizza smelled and tasted like Natural Gas. When I went to leave this review, I saw another review that said the same thing from several days ealier. I've ordered from the Lincroft location about 5 times. They're sort of inconsistent with quality of pizza. Sometimes I like the crust, somtimes it's too thin. Sometimes the flavor of the pizza is good, sometimes not enough flavor. Today the crust was too thin and I think a little under done. I called the restaurant to tell them about the gas smell/taste. I talked to a female manager, she said she'd look out for any...

Unfortunately, I forgot to take the usual food pics. I do so I only got a picture of the half-and-half pie, which was delicious. It is super cute inside, and I was not expecting that when you see the front of the store. I don’t know if our server was new or anything, but that was the only thing lacking from our experience. The Arrabiata sauce was delicious, the garlic knots were tasty, the Stromboli was huge and delicious. It’s a great value with great food and...

Had a great experience at Attilios! We went in for dinner. It was BYOB which was great, the liquor store is right next door which is convenient. Service was great! I had the Chicken Francese and it was top notch. My boyfriend had the pan seared shrimp and scallops and he loved it. We have since ordered take out twice and the meals are just as good as dining in. Its a...