Jerry's Pizza — Restaurant in Middletown

(Last visited 3/31/2022.) Every Wednesday Jerry's hosts music bingo with a chance win all kinds of free prizes, so needless to say I've been here quite a few times not only for that, but for their delicious wings! Let's begin!

Atmosphere/Appearance: This place is pretty much a dive. Lol. Not a bad dive. It doesn't present a risk of being killed or harmed in the parking lot, but once inside and you hang out for a minute, you'll understand. Lol. There is a private parking lot on the side of the building that Jerry's shares with a couple of other businesses. It's an elongated sort of restaurant with a drop ceiling, many TVs a slightly raised "stage", a pool table toward the back and a big bar rail on the right side. Like I mentioned, it's a dive, so it's loud in here.

Service: I can't remember all of the servers names who took care of us, but I've never actually had an issue here. Things are fine, nothing like a fine dining restaurant, but it's all good.

Food: I'm here for the wings! Throughout my numerous visits I've had their Bacon Ranch, Sweet 'N' Hot, Marinara Parmesan, Cinnamon Chipotle and Honey BBQ flavors. They're all very good, a decent size and full of flavor.

Value: I feel like there's some sort of #WingWednesday special on the same Wednesday where there's music bingo, but I'm drawing a blank on what exactly is. Lol. Just trust me.

In conclusion, this place is cool. I'm not gonna pull up on my own merit, but if some folks wanna get together to play some music bingo and get some wings,...

Jerry’s used to be good pizza. Now? It’s like they gave up and decided “lazy and disgusting” was the new recipe. The meatballs tasted like they’d been rolled by someone who hates their job, and the pizza… my God. A gooey, slimy, greasy mess where everything slides off the second you pick it up. I’ve seen toddlers hold their diapers together better than this pizza holds its toppings.

Update: The owner wanted me to “give them another chance.” No. My father—an authentic Italian who knows real pizza—took one bite and said, “This is the worst pizza I’ve ever had in my life.” I agree. I’m not out to ruin your business, I’m just telling the truth. People on Facebook backed me up—sure, a few said “eat in” is better, but delivery shouldn’t be the trash-tier knockoff of your in-house food. Jerry’s, you’ve gone from being a local favorite to a sad, greasy shadow of what you used to be. If this is you “trying,” I’d hate to see you on...

I moved to Middletown about 3 years ago and when I first moved here Jerry’s was always my go to! Even Mattys next door, we’ll recently my past two orders I’ve places were not good! The first one I ordered a specialty pizza half and half which is not cheap might I add and when I got home the cheese was sliding off the pizza it was slop! Also the fried buffalo ravioli with the blue cheese is my all time favorite which I order every time I come. Well tonight I came in to pick up my half pepperoni half bacon pizza and friend buffalo ravioli over 30$ I get home open pizza same thing cheese falling off bacon is extremely under cooked and my friend buffalo ravioli has 2 less pieces than normal and sour cream instead of the delicious blue cheese I always get. Sad to say this is the last time I’ll be ordering from Jerry’s. I know you guys are extremely busy but I don’t think this is good service. I’d gladly wait longer for...