Outlaw Oyster — Restaurant in Milwaukee

I hate being the first review but also maybe it’ll give some guidance to be better moving forward. The food was absolutely amazing! Little pricey for the portion but given the new area I understand The atmosphere was amazing. However the service needs a little extra love, the bartender was very informative nor inviting. I don’t think she smiled, at all honestly.

I asked her to check about a nut allergy for the ceasar, she didn’t seem very concerning about it nor just even cared to give me an answer about if it contained any nuts period. I had to ask after she claimed to have asked the chef..

She rang in the wrong bottle of wine that was 10$ more and when I told her she looked at the bottles like she didn’t know which one was which? It’s 2 white wines they carry.. if you’re going to have someone in the food industry allergies should be important and if they are bartending they should not be confused between 2 wines that are completely different.

Maybe some more training, also had to ask for everything (side plates, forks, napkins) working in the industry myself I guess I’m a bit of a high expectation girly but I play fair when it comes to stuff.

A nut allergy should not be brushed off when it could literally kill someone. Still tipped 20% of course and still would go back...

I think this is my new favorite restaurant in Milwaukee. They have a great selection of wine and even have skin contact wine (which is a must try) The menu is cultivating, interesting, and refreshing. The tin fish options are phenomenal and always rotating and the oysters are chef’s kiss. The oysters are fresh and delicate in the palate. I would recommend everyone giving it a try (even if it’s a little scary if you haven’t...

I have visited the Tosa location but we wanted to give the Bayview location a try. It did not disappoint! We were there on a Wednesday so it was happy hour all day. I probably ate more oysters than I should have. And the octodog was out of this world amazing! Service and ambiance was great as well. I...