Bavellie's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Monroe Township

Last night’s dinner: 10 out of 10 would absolutely order again. My husband and I have gotten carry out multiple times from Bavellie’s, and it has been very consistent and good every time. I don’t quite understand any of the negative or bad reviews on here-if you order the food online you have options to customize your food order however you like! You can customize to lightly done/regular bake/well done, light sauce/extra sauce/regular sauce, etc. I’ve found a regular bake and regular sauce is exactly what I like on my pizza-it has a nice crisp to the edges and the perfect amount of sauce. All of the specialty pizzas I’ve tried have been really good-the Hawaiian, the veggie, and the triple meat pizza are delicious and have a great amount of toppings. We always get an Italian sub too! Honestly I prefer this pizza to any of the other pizza options in Johnstown-I won’t name names but I’ve been disappointed by other places here that people allegedly love. I would go here before any of the other options in town for sure

They are open for dinner only which hasn’t been an issue for me-generally if I want this type of food, I want it for dinner and they do open at 4:30 which is a reasonable time to open for dinner service. We’ll...

1st time trying Bavellie's. Not too impressed. We got a large Pepperoni and Mushroom--Pizza was floppy and undercooked, VERY salty (not sure if it was the pepperoni, or the sauce), and just didn't taste that great. Looking at the pictures of their pizzas on their Facebook site, I assumed it would be similar---a slightly thicker crust. Ours was paper thin and crispy on the crust edge, but sloppy thin on the rest of the slice. I know this is a matter of opinion, but it doesn't stand up to the other places in town that are much better (Pizza Villa, Uncle Johnnies, Dirko's). I ordered delivery, and I literally took only 15 minutes after I hung up the phone to my doorbell ringing.....seems like they had something pre-made possibly....how do you make, cook, and deliver in less than 15 minutes? I guess that explains why it was undercooked. We also ordered the garlic bread with cheese---at least THAT was great! Sorry to say, we'll probably not be ordering from...

The staff was very polite and the pizza is fantastic! Ordered a large pizza and cheesy breadstick on a Friday around 7 and it was ready when they said it would be ready. Has an amazing under crust! I like a slightly burnt under crust and it was to perfection for my taste. Some people get crazy with their toppings which is fun but sometimes you got to just keep things simple and stick with the basics. The pepperoni was nice and crispy and covered the entire pizza and had so much flavor. I also felt the price was reasonable and fair. Totally my new favorite spot in town and I'll most definitely be ordering from them the most from now on! Thanks Bavellie's Pizzeria for making this pizza...