Hogback Pizza — Restaurant in New Castle

During our getaway weekend in Newcastle, we stopped by this cozy pizza spot on our first night—it was conveniently located just across the street from where we were staying. From the moment we walked in, we were impressed by the unique pizza options on the menu. Honestly, if I lived in Newcastle, I’d make it my mission to try every single one!

For my boyfriend’s birthday celebration, we decided to go all out and ordered two different pizzas: the Traditional Neglect and the Fu Manchu. Both were absolutely delicious! The flavors were bold, and the pizzas had that perfect homemade touch. The thin, flat crust reminded me a bit of MOD Pizza but with a more elevated, handcrafted vibe. Even though we were stuffed, the leftovers made for excellent midnight snacks during our stay.

Each pizza was around $25, including tip, which felt reasonable for the quality and portion size. The workers were friendly, and the atmosphere of the place added to the experience. It’s a smaller establishment—fitting for a small town—but they made great use of the space with a bar and even a couple of arcade games, which added a fun touch.

If you’re in Newcastle and craving pizza, this is the place to go. Highly recommended for a casual, delicious meal in a...

Best pizza on earth.

Thin crust square cut wood fired. Heaven in your mouth, no exaggeration. Better than any food in Aspen. I lived here 2.5 years ago and still dream about this place.

I compare everything I’ve tried since then to this place and nothing compares. The best pizza I’ve found in the world. Beats everything I tried living in Seattle Denver and MPLS. My wife and I move back in FEB and the first thing we are doing is grabbing a supreme thin crust pizza from you all and devour it in the parking lot!

We literally time of summer hiking trips around your hours so we can stop to and from and grab a pie. I’m not a business owner but I’ve half jokingly told my wife if we ever do want to own one, I’d ask the owner about franchise opportunities because pizza recipe they got is gold Jerry,...

This place definitely has a backyard BBQ feel to it. The staff are comfortable and very friendly. They only had outdoor seating under a tent right now so if you're staying, be aware of the weather. The Pizza is great. Their style reminds me of Beau Jo's. The cheesy breadsticks are also popular. I would compare them to Pizza Huts, except you can tell Hogback's ingredients are really fresh. my only issue is that the tables are wobbly and we spilled our drinks several times when another table's dog kept bumping into our table. One time our whole pizza almost fell off. It's was a weird situation because the staff (understandably) didn't want a scene and the other party was just trying to ignore the situation. I love dogs, but for crying out loud, please keep an eye on your pet. Pretty...