MAGUEY RESTAURANT — Restaurant in New York

It hurts me to write this review, I came in with high expectations and was disappointed. The tortas are not really the size I'm used to from eating at other Mexican restaurants, The torta was extremely disappointing and I don't really agree with the prices, The prices are a little better at other Mexican restaurants. The torta was small, greasy, and looked like something I could put together at home. The service was great, and atmosphere was alright, but I don't think I would come back to this place again. Maybe I came in at a bad time, because all the other reviews seem to be good, but my experience was the opposite. I'm really happy I didn't have my friends and family with me dining here. I suggest other Mexican restaurants in the...

Some places just get it right. From the moment we walked in, this spot exuded effortless charm—warm lighting, tasteful decor, and an atmosphere that said, “Stay awhile.” And stay we did, thanks to the incredibly kind and patient staff who didn’t rush us out the door when we stayed a bit after closing.

While we didn’t dive into the full menu this time, we did get to try the Choco Flan which was solid, good enough to be mentioned.

The drinks on the other hand, On point. The service? Even better. Our waitress was the kind of person you wish could follow you around in life, making every experience just a little bit nicer.

We’ll definitely be back—next time, with...

I was short on time and needed a quick bite. I am on a strict diet. I explained to the lady what I can eat and she offered me the most delicious and huge chicken salad. The place has a clean bathroom and the seating area is clean. I appreciated the fact that the place to sit did not smell like food or any cleaning detergents marks or smells. The code was great as well. I could not finish the salad and asked it to go. I forgot to leave a tip so I will definitely come back again and support...