Sugarboy Bakery — Restaurant in New York

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I’ve been coming to this bakery for almost two years now, and they never disappoint! Every single time, the service, presentation, and taste are absolutely perfect. My kids love their cakes, my family loves them, and everyone who comes to our events always asks where I got them from. The cakes are beautiful, moist, and full of flavor you can tell they put love and care into every detail.

What I really appreciate is how well they communicate throughout the whole process. They respond quickly, are super helpful, and make sure to confirm every detail. If you’re unsure of what you want, they’ll even show you different design and flavor options to help you decide. It really makes the experience stress-free and enjoyable.

The prices are very reasonable for the quality you get, and they always deliver exactly what I asked for sometimes even better than I imagined! The flavors are amazing, the cakes are very filling, and they’re always a hit at every event.

I’ve ordered for birthdays, holidays, and special occasions, and they always go above and beyond. I recommend this bakery...

This review is for a pre-made tres leches cake that I purchased for my daughter's birthday. She loves Tres Leche Cake. I was expecting a smooth and moist cake with a tasty frosting and not overly sweet filling. However, I was very disappointed with the cake. The cake was dry and grainy. The frosting was bland and left a weird after taste. There wasn’t enough filling as you see in the picture. There were two layers and not spread evenly. The filling/custard wasn’t sweet but it didn’t have a creamy flavor. The design of the cake was cute,. I was surprised with the frosting on top that it didn’t need. The flowers should had been laid directly to the top of the cake. Overall, I was very disappointed with the Tres Leche cake and it was not worth the price I paid. The cake will be eaten as a cake to be eaten along with some coffee, because I’m not throwing my money in the trash. It’s a crime to throw food away.

Lesson learned: Always ask questions about pre-made cakes. I didn’t ask any. If available , buy a slice before you buy a whole cake. You’ll have something to compare it...

I am not sure why this bakery has 4 stars, they are extremely overpriced and the cakes are not good. The cake I purchased was very dry and it tasted old, let me mention I purchased the tres leche cake and if that cake was dry that itself says it all. How do you sell a small tres leche cake that in another great bakery is normally no more than $25 because it’s a very small cake for $40 and not be an amazing cake, such a disappointment. I normally purchase all my cakes from Capri Bakery in the bx (btw I get a tres leche cake from Capri for $35 and it’s three times the size of the $40 cake from Sugarboy and it’s fresh and moist) anyways, I recently moved and decided to check Sugarboy out because of the star rating but boy was that a mistake. Never again!!! I am Thankful I didn’t purchase the exact very small cake but with decorations for...