Taqueria Coatzingo — Restaurant in New York

Coatzingo Taquería is one of those places that truly makes a difference when you’re looking for authentic Mexican food in New York. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere immediately transports you to Mexico. The entire decoration is fully Mexican, filled with details that make you feel as if you were eating tacos at a traditional market. That authenticity sets it apart and makes the whole experience so much more special than just going to a regular taco spot.

The food is outstanding. I tried several tacos, and without a doubt, the tripe taco was the best I’ve ever had—perfectly cooked, with amazing flavor and just the right texture. The al pastor tacos are also delicious, with a truly authentic taste that’s hard to find outside of Mexico. The guacamole has excellent flavor, fresh and well-prepared, although I did find the portion quite small compared to the $10 price. Still, I have to admit the taste itself was really good.

The service is another highlight. The person who took care of my table was attentive, always checking in and making great recommendations to make sure I had a good experience from start to finish. That kind of hospitality makes a big difference and is definitely appreciated.

If there’s one thing I would add, it would be Mexican music playing in the background. The place already has the authentic décor and amazing food, and adding traditional music would complete the atmosphere and make it feel 100% like being in Mexico.

Overall, Coatzingo Taquería is definitely a place I recommend if you’re in New York and want to enjoy real tacos. The quality of the food, the unique Mexican atmosphere, and the good service make it worth the visit. If you’re looking for a spot that takes you to Mexico with every bite, this is...

Street parking, and it is a very difficult challenge here as they are located at a very busy street, however the subway is extremely close so taking the train is the best option.

There are 2 restaurants and they are connected. They have different names, but coming in through either of them is fine.

Quick service the waitress sat us and gave us menus super quick, she took drink orders quickly as well. pretty good I think.

Menu with pics, that was very helpful I think cause I got to see some of the meals before I could decide to order.

MOJITO- nice and strong. Amazing size drink. Has a lot of mint and that was pretty great

ENCHILADA DE MOLE POBLANO- I got the enchiladas with cheese. The mole was pretty nice and spicy, spicier than I am used to but none the less pretty nice. I asked for a side of sour cream and it never came. I was sad about that course it could have helped with the spicy mole. The cheese in the mole was not all melted as well.

FLAN- lots of vanilla extract and the texture was a little off. A lot less moist than I hoped but it tasted ok, nothing special really. I would pass it up. I was a bit disappointed.

My friend also ordered some tacos that they forgot to bring and we had to ask for them again. the taco took a long time.

So yes the initial service is pretty fast cause they sit you right away with menus and water but the follow up after the food comes out lacks a lot.

The overall seems to be a ok. The place has a lot to improve as far as service follow up while food is on the table. The food was nice with large portions but the taste was very basic.

Good...

I’ve been eating at this restaurant since 2007 and have tried many of the menu items throughout the years. This is my favorite Mexican restaurant in NY. I’ve tried several different Mexican restaurants and food trucks, and so far, this is the most authentic and delicious in flavor that I’ve experienced in New York. It reminds me of the hole-in-the-wall restaurants I’ve eaten at in Puerto Vallarta.

There are other Mexican spots in the area that taste authentic, but the quality and flavor don’t compare to this restaurant. The food here is very flavorful and excellent in quality! The way they season their dishes is just so good.

My favorite is the quesadillas mixtas with rice and frijoles (so creamy and delicious here). I also really like their horchatas, jugo de tamarindo, and their piña coladas—the perfect balance of sweetness and alcohol. My favorite piña coladas on Roosevelt Ave come from this place 🙌🏽. The consistency is spot on: not too watery, not too thick.

They also serve delicious nachos, salsa, guac, burritos, fajitas—you name it. Their complimentary salsa is my absolute favorite! It’s homemade, a little sweet, a little spicy, and absolutely delicious.

I love this place so much that I’ve been a loyal customer for...