Bummie's On Main — Restaurant in Ohio

We were very happy to see Bummie’s come back after the original place burned down - it’s been a cherished hometown dining spot for decades. I had the fish sandwich and it was 5 stars. The burgers remain the absolute top of the list, service is fast and friendly no matter the server you get, and the decor is sort of Sixties retro. Everything I’ve ever ordered there has been delicious. Service is always attentive. The atmosphere is loud because the place is always hopping with families and groups having fun and telling stories and laughing, sometimes loudly. It’s that kind of place! 😊 but if noise is an issue for you, this might bother you. The tables and aisles are pretty close together so I’m not sure of handicapped accessibility other than to say that given the friendliness of the staff, I am sure they would do their best, but the aisle where we last sat was definitely not wide enough for a wheelchair and was tough to maneuver with a cane. The parking lot is ten times what the old place had but still can be a little difficult to maneuver around in because it’s always packed and the spaces are tight, and since it sits on a corner, can sometimes be a little tough to exit, depending on when you’re there. It’s next to the football stadium and it’s a very popular hometown spot, so plan your visit time accordingly; you might have a long wait to get in. (The host will tell you what the wait time is when you enter) I always tell people to visit Bummie’s, especially if they ask me where to get the best...

We love going here so here are my pros & cons:

Pros:

Great food. I love the Chicken Tenders. The pizza is a little pricy but amazing. Fries aren't bad. Apps are delicious! Service is pretty good! The vibe is pretty good!

Cons: Online ordering continues to only be for Pizza, Salads and Subs. Anything else you need to come in and wait for. Website menu says "Out of stock" on a lot of things. I am sure most of their menu isn't, but it may lead to confusion. Parking is a major issue because the place is on the corner. Turning in to or out of the parking lot using the W. Main St entrance can be dangerous being so close to the stop light. Turning into or out of the N. 11th St side is a little better, but getting in if the light is red may take a minute. The lot needs to be restriped. The stripes are so faded it's hard to see sometimes and people just make up the spots. The tables are a little too close and it does get crowded and thus loud. After the original location on N. Cedar St burned down, I am surprised that this location is small too. They have no problem filling every seat in this place so I thought it would have been larger.

I know I have more "cons" than "pros" but definitely give this place a shot. It's delicious and you will be glad...

Newark's best keep secret. Drove past this place for years. What looks like a dive bar from the outside actually has the best food in Newark. I would have never guessed! I've been here three times attempting to order a burger, but I can't get past the daily specials. The chicken sandwich is hearty and juicy, fish was cooked to perfection, and Reuben is the best in town. Whoever works the kitchen definitely knows what they are doing. Prices are great for the quality and portion you receive. If I had to find something to criticize, it would be the atmosphere. What looks like a dive bar from the outside also feels like a dive bar on the inside. CCR on the jukebox and domestic beer advertising on all the walls, but that is the demographic in Newark, so I can't be mad about it. Overall, I 100% recommend for anyone. Can't wait to try the burger!

EDIT: To the owner - I have had everything on your menu multiple times, but I have not tried your burger yet. Please add more traditional options to your Burger Menu (Bacon Cheeseburger, Black n Bleu, BBQ Cheddar). I understand that I can create my own, but I am not a chef and quite frankly I do not want to make those decisions when...