Cutter's Pizzeria of Oxford — Restaurant in Oxford

I have to leave a review for this place, in hopes they never have to close for lack of business! By far the best pizza for miles! We've tried several items like the Holy Smokes on hand tossed. You can get it in any style, Chicago, deep dish, etc. The way they load those toppings onto a hand tossed crust is a thing of beauty!!! I haven't tasted a pizza that delicious since I was a kid in Roebuck, ordering from Big Daddy's pizza. I wish my parents were still alive to try it. Big Daddy's supreme was always their benchmark, and they never found another one that was on par, in over 30 years. But I finally have :) We also tried the Wisconsin 6 cheese on deep dish, and if you dream of the ultimate cheesy pizza with a buttery crust, this will make you think you've found paradise. I must be honest and say my son didn't really care for his pasta, but maybe they'll read this and give it a tweak. He loves their cheese fries, and everyone was so impressed with the pizza! One thing is for sure, no one in this house will ever be truly satisfied with Dom or PJohns again. If you are anywhere near, go there for your next pizza night. And give them a good tip! They definitely don't go cheap on their customers. Next time, I'm...

I will NEVER go here again, ordered 4 pizzas and when we hot home and sat the boxes on the counter 2 roaches crawled out of the center fold of one of the boxes, needless to say we tossed over 100$ worth of pizza and spent the next week worried about roaches in the car and house.. After seeing cutters response I'm beyond shocked, you go so far as to say I'm deliberately trying to hurt your business and ask why I posted something 2 weeks ago, ((because you had roaches in the pizza box you sent me home with)).. let me clear something up for you yes I said one was on my kitchen counter and the other was still in the center fold of the pizza box. As for the roaches riding in my car for 5 minutes are you kidding me, I suggest you talk to your exterminator, he will tell you that roaches love cardboard. I assure you my home does not have roaches. The sad part of all of this is you take no responsibility and blame the customer. Hopefully the health inspector is...

Editing now for the third time. Went back again and probably should have left well enough alone. Again ordered the pie and apparently who ever made this one either doesn't like sauce, ran out of sauce or just forgot that sauce goes on a pizza. Now 75.00 bucks in the owner is going to ask. "What can we do Better? Perhaps a consistent product would be a good place to start. It won't be covid that shuts this place down in 12 months

As an update to my original review on the chicago style (below). I ordered The Pie tonight. May be one of the best pizzas i have had. Certainly the best in Oxford hands down

was looking forward to the Chicago style pizza. Am thinking who ever made the "Chicago Style" pizza should go to...