Pizzarelli Restaurant — Restaurant in Perth Amboy

On Christmas Sunday these people took 20 min just to place my simple order of chicken marsala, pasta and a greek salad. They took an hr. I called back to inquire how long my food would be delivered and then they said it will be 20 more minutes. Then I said I want my car to be refunded for the charge and they said they couldn't. Then I had to tell them I would never order from their restaurant again because they were liars and telling me how long it would take for my food to be delivered. Not only that they didn't even know how to put the order together. I have no idea why this place has five stars it must be friends or family members that have boosted this place up. Technically they are very unprofessional and I ordered pizza from them before and it wasn't that great. I will never ever in a million thousand, hundred thousand years order from here again and if I was you I...

This is thee best Italian restaurant in all of Perth Amboy! The food is excellent and fresh. Their pizza is totally NYC style and taste. Yet the cost is basically half the price of NY. Their numerous lunch specials are well put together and a bargain. You cannot beat the price. Their pastas are on point and delicious. Great quality true Italian! "Thee best Chicken Francese I have ever had." And I have had a lot over the years. It has to be tried to be believed. The people working there are friendly, polite and attentive. Very fair-priced, quality Italian at its finest. Thanks guys for being in Perth Amboy. I don't know where I would order such great food without you. You're spot on. I work in NYC and would put Pizzarelli up against any pizzeria restaurant I've been to there. Richard P. ...

Very disappointed with the pizza from here. Asked for pepperoni and all they did was throw the pepperoni on a plane slice. Didn't heat it up enough and when u picked up my pizza to eat all my pepperoni fell off. I mean add a little bit more cheese so the pepperoni doesn't fall off. Kids just talking loud to each other 1 foot away from each other. Servers on the cell phones so they dont hear what we ask for so we have to repeat myself multiple time. Just a horrible experience, very disappointed since I moved to Florida and was looking forward for a good slice from Jersey where im from. Unfortunately I was totally disappointed. I probably won't ever come back to this location and advise my people's that live in jersey to...