Stefano’s Pizza — Restaurant in Petaluma

This place has the best pizza in town that I’ve tried.

So delicioso that you think you’re in Italy!

And they got IPA as well as Sierra Nevada, Modelo and Corona on tap!

I’ve been here now three different times before and enjoyed it each time immensely. Ordered by phone for pick up but decided to eat in after all because I could use the company and the atmosphere is so welcoming.

Tonight I’m having a small pie with 100% high quality mozzarella, Italian sausage (they also have hot sausage - some like it hot!), salami, double mushroom, red bell pepper, red onion, fresh garlic and tomato which I had them add in the final cook, and “well done” so the salami and sausage crisp up. The crust is a perfect medium thick, chewy, not undercooked like some others, and crispy at the end.

Also got a delicious Greek salad - and their balsamic dressing is killer! Not overly sweet nor too acidic.

A coke for a little sugar w/ a lift. And…

to seal the deal, a home baked look-alike (Woodbine Bakery, out of San Rafael) m and m chocolate chip cookie. Nothing like the m and m cookie to make me a happy camper! And for good measure, I also took home a lemon glazed tea cake which tastes quite a bit like a giant Madeline cookie, with a nice dose of lemon.

Ambiance: Great lighting, comfortable seating, even has a couple pizza parlor style booths, giant screen tv playing ball and football. Very clean, and good vibes!

Thanks Stefanos for a great...

I was really excited about trying this place because pizza by the slice can either be really amazing or extremely disappointing. Sadly I was disappointed with how dry the pizza was the crust was equivalent to biting into a stale cracker it says a lot about a place and how they value quality when they keep product out longer than they should. Taking shortcuts to make more profit is yucky especially considering how cheap it is to make pizza when you're buying inventory in bulk. My friends I've also been here a couple times and they said it can be either really greasy or extremely stale and that's...

We ordered an extra large, came out thin and undercooked, even though I never ordered a thin crust. The wings tasted old like they were re fried and dry, and the chicken inside was nasty. I've never been to a pizza place where the pizza was made with no love. I was very disappointed coming here. Pizza should taste good, cheese should be ozzing and crust should be cooked more. I would suggest the cook put more time in cooking pizza. I've never really ever had a bad...