Tomato City Pizza — Restaurant in Providence

Ordered an XL (it's the rectangular size) cheese w/their old school Italian sauce & a large pepperoni half pineapple w/the same sauce. Price was reasonable, delivery came way way faster than the slice app said it would which absolutely shocked me & I feel bad because apparently the delivery driver didn't see where I checked off for them to just leave it at my door. She called me like five times & I wasn't able to get to the phone right away. Whoops! At least I gave a 15% tip prior (which you should always do!). Ok on to the pizza.. The crust is excellent 10/10. It almost tastes like they rub the pans with garlic butter or oil? Old school Italian sauce was really good but just a touch too sweet for my taste 8.5/10. The cheese was too much & I mean like they could've put 1/3 the amount & it would've been perfect! Not only was it super difficult for us to chew & swallow, but it made everything a super greasy mess. If you love extra extra cheese, you will be so happy,but I don't so 2/10. The pepperoni was great, good flavor, not too spicy, perfect amount. Pineapple was typical canned tidbits, & they put way way too much & also covered more than half the pizza with it. Whoops. It was still a good pie! I would order again but would need to ask that they use a third the amount of cheese. I mean dang, cheese is expensive & you could save your business a pretty penny if you scaled back a little on that cuz it's wildly ridiculous how much you use! I give the rectangular cheese 7/10 & the pepperoni 1/2...

This is only the second review I've ever done in my life and the other one was positive but I just had to comment. Please do not waste your money here! Whatever you do, do not get the deep dish! Absolutely horrendous and disgusting. Inedible. Not trying to be rude but I am not picky at all with food and I threw out over three quarters of the pizza. Usually I can try to doctor it up, put it back in the oven, perhaps add something but this was beyond help. I ate less than one slice and I literally feel sick. Way way too much greasy cheese, very skimpy on the toppings, dough was raw under the soupy mess even though I asked for it well done anticipating it would be a thicker pizza. Meatballs (maybe four or five thin slices on a small pizza) were way too spicy and horrible w hardly any sauce. Chicken tenders were very large and decent enough but again just drowning in sauce which just ruins it. Wings are ok... Were still over-sauced but edible. Spent almost 40 bucks with tip for them to drive less than a mile. Driver barely acknowledged the tip and might have muttered a thank you. Couldn't really tell. He couldn't even be bothered to come up to the door and made me come out in the rain to the gate. The person taking the order was nice enough but the quality of the food is extremely disappointing. I am not one to waste or throw out food but it was completely unacceptable in my opinion. Wish they would put a little more care into their product. $ down the drain....

Ordered a pizza online through their website. When I went to pick it up, they told me they didn't have the order. Confused, I asked why and was told repeatedly, "We don't have it". I asked them what am I supposed to do now? And was met with shrugs and "I don't know" "we don't have it" from 2 people working there. I pressed on saying I paid my money and wanted a pizza, finally asking if they could make me one now and was told I should have called first. I said, I'm standing right here now, I can't order a pizza??!! They reluctantly agreed to take my order and then proceeded to talk about me in Spanish amongst themselves. I speak enough Spanish to know they were talking about me. It felt like the Twilight Zone. They kept saying they have "nothing to do with the website" and that I should call instead.... I could go on with more about their utter contempt for their customers and lack of anything that resembles customer service but suffice it to say they were rude, disrespectful, unhelpful, complacent, and extremely poorly trained in their job. The place is also a dump and I almost tripped on the uneven, poorly lit steps on the way out. Awful and...