Ohio Pie Co Rocky River — Restaurant in Rocky River

I have very mixed feelings about this place.

We got our usual toppings of olives and banana peppers. It tasted like when I was little and made pizza with my mom at home. And we used the crust from a tube from the grocery story. It was soft and fluffy. But not what I’m looking for when I’m ordering pizza from a restaurant. It was almost like a croissant roll bread with pizza toppings, instead of a pizza. Overall, I really wouldn’t get it again.

However, I really LOVE LOVE LOVED the sauce !

We also got the white pizza (I don’t remember the fun name it had) and I thought it was really tasty. If someone wanted to go back here, this is the pizza I would personally get for myself.

Also, we showed up 15 minutes before our scheduled time and our pizza was already done. So idk how long it was waiting there! Just a heads up to get there early so you get the freshest pie.

THE BIGGEST STAR OF THIS PLACE IS THE COOKIES!!!!!!! Holy cow!!!! The cookies are 5 stars!!!!!! The tiramisu cookie was so good, we went back the next day and got more. They were stuffed with gooey goodness inside. I AM SALIVATING just thinking...

Wow. So glad I decided to make a stop here. I drove from Sandusky on the hunt for a good brunch and found myself ordering pizza when I saw they offered brunch pies.

I called in my order with ease and it was ready promptly and on time. I grabbed the pies and a cookie and was on my way.

I decided to try it in the car while it was hot and fresh. I enjoyed both pies. The heartburner was perfect. It's basically a double pepperoni double cheese. I liked their crust a lot. I would say it was a hybrid grandma style. Oddly enough in round form.

I'm used to Grandma style pies being square.

The brunch pie needed a bit more sauce and I'd probably go without the eggs next time, but I still enjoyed it.

I thought they used too much garlic oil. The pizza was greasy and oily for no reason. I think it would taste good even without that or maybe they can just brush the edge with it.

Other than that, I enjoyed it and will definitely try to make...

Total bummer. We are big time fans of the Brunswick location. My wife usually gets a basic B, and I get a large V pickle chip and V fire bird, and cookies. We try to keep it under once a month, because we can spend a car note here a month. We were NEVER disappointed at Brunswick. This doesn't even seem like the same place. The counter person seemed irritated we disturbed her from hanging out in the back. The food itself was pitiful. I was missing a main component of my BBQ V chicken thing, the onion portion, and there was just over 50% cheese coverage. Like, it was just bread for almost half of it. If you've visited here, do NOT let this shop represent Ohio Pie!! I do not know what's going on here, but the drive to Brunswick is well worth it for the proper setup. We have been loyal fans for years, please please give the Brunswick...