Nueva Italy Pizzeria — Restaurant in Rogers Park Township

Good pizza, just extremely inconsistent. One time delivery took way too long and pizza wasn't hot. Next time we ordered, we gave our address for delivery. An hour later... we called asking for our pizza and it was marked as pick up. Again, no hot pizza. This last time we ordered a deep dish. We ordered extra tomato and so they put nearly no pizza sauce and didn't honor a replacement with good costumer service. They want the bad pizza back. That's fine, it just shows a lack of trust being loyal costumers for 2 years. This will be the last time we order unfortunately. JB's is consistent. I've once had a fallen pizza delivered and JB's made up for it for 2 following orders. Giordanos is consistent. Even Little Ceasars is consistent. There's too much compitition to be dropping the ball. Great pizza, better then the competition. Just dine-in and watch them...

Ordered a small thin crust with extra cheese and black olives and a caesar salad. It was enough for two and it was fantastic. It was around 20 bucks (including delivery) plus tip, which I was okay with. Any time I order pizza in the city I expect to pay around 20 bucks for just the pizza. I live fairly close and waited about 45 minutes, but to be fair the weather was awful. Still, not a bad wait time. The pizza and the salad were both very good. The thin crust is not that thin, which I liked. It is thinner than hand tossed, and more than sturdy enough to not droop but not overly crispy either. The sauce is unique, very bright and savory, and the cheese was excellent. I will be getting my next...

Unexpected surprise! This has been down the street all these years and I never knew. I wanted to try something different, so listened to some reviews and ordered the thin, butter crust from Nueva Italy. The crust was delicious and crispy, and the sauce is top notch. As a bonus, the delivery driver was also incredibly friendly. I will have to try the deep dish next time, but I highly recommend the butter crust. Apparently this is one place that ordering by phone can be better than grubhub or their website though, as they sometimes have specials only...