Mountain Mike's Pizza — Restaurant in Santa Maria

We ordered a Lg. Mt. Veggiemore and substituted the tomato's for pepperoni. Overall the Pizza had an excellent smoky flavor, however, the crust was so thick that the dough never cooked past 1" of the crust, it is not safe to eat uncooked dough, I actually was nauseous from it. The green peppers were cut way too big, overtook the pie. Maybe it's preference but we also felt it needed more pizza sauce. That being said, if we ordered it again, would have to go like this: Mt. Veggiemore, substitute tomatos for pepperoni, thinner crust (not an option), much smaller pieces of peppers or none at all, and extra sauce. Now consider the substitution of pepperoni for tomato raised the price by $3.00 ????? I could have gotten an all meat for the same price! Add $5.00 coupon, should be $21.75 + tax 1.58 = $23.33, If I eliminate an item, such as the green peppers do I get an additional $3.00 off, considering it was added when substituting? We paid $27.18 We stopped going to Pizza Hut because of uncooked pizza dough. We live just a stones throw from your store and only just tried it now because others have said similar things, the price, too thick......Your ad claims the best pizza in Santa Maria, you have heavy competition out there, Blaze, LaVera, Klondike, etc. Santa Maria is finicky...

The ingredients tasted excellent and high quality. I ordered carry out and the pizza was hot although a little bit later than promised from the time I asked for it to be finished as I ordered ahead. The Everest was very tasty but could have used more bell pepper and onions. Friends had the garlic Tuscan and said that it could have tasted more garlicky as it says garlic in the title or name of pizza. Overall tasty and very good ingredients quality. I would like to try eating in-house the next time and try and the beer on tap with my pizza. Seating is a little limited though as it's not a giant type of establishment but cozy enough. There are many TVs with different sports on at once on each TV. The staff was friendly and the restaurant had that mom-and-pop...

Came to Mountain Mikes 30 mins before closing and walked up to locked doors. When a lady came out I went to try the door again since both the website and the outside had an open sign. Online said open til 12 am so I placed an online order to pick up and pay in store. I then saw the manager come out from the back and call me to tell me that they are no longer accepting orders only through doordash and he would have to cancel my order. I feel he purposely waited to call me after 9:40 since doordash does not accept orders past that time. He also rudely told me they close at 10 which is incorrect online and he should have a request for it to be changed through HR or whoever is in charge. I feel it is lazy to close early and treat customers...