So, now that I've tried a little something from every other seletion avaiable on the menu, I can happily say this is now my GO-TO for pizza, pasta, salad, AND wings. I was a diehard fan of another pizza and wing franchise, who shan't be named because honnestly they should be ashamed of themselves and I should be too because the audacity of me to have called them my true love for so long. TOO LONG. But that is NO MORE. A close relative introduced me to Holy Pie a few months ago, and now it's like I literally cannot go two months without getting me something from this place of business. My most recent delicacy was the their yummy, delicious, can't hardly eat it because it slips right off the bone garlic parmesan wings (with a ranch dipping sauce). I don't know what they're paying that chef for him to be so absolutey selfless with the amout of garlic parmesan sauce he had blessed me with, but (if you're reading this, chef) I will double it. Triple it if you can slide a dozen and one one of those also somehow magically falling apart at the seams and yet amazingly still staying together enough for me to cry through my first, second, and third bite chocolate chip cookies my way. 1000000/10, DO AND...
Read more9/26/23 around 700pm I called in an order so food would be ready when I got off from Memorial , sadly I thought I had called order in to the location on Waters Ave but i had called the location in Garden City …. When I went to pickup order at Waters Ave at 7:30 pm they didn’t have my order …. Well the ladies at the counter (sorry I didn’t get their names) but the one that was taking the orders called other location and figured that I had called to the wrong location but they took my order with no problem and cooked my order expeditiously…. The food was great as always… but the 1 thing that stood out the most was the lady at register kept apologizing to me … she didn’t even have to apologize bcuz it wasn’t her fault it was mine for calling the wrong place and she walked my food to me while I waited on the bench but thank you thank you ma’am for...
Read moreI ordered take out/pick up. Ordered the hamburger pizza, no onions. What I got was a pizza with ground beef, tons of small cubed tomatoes, and super thick slices of pickles. The problem for me was, it was supposed to have "burger sauce" lettuce which o didn't get any of that. It was basically a dry hamburger pizza with tomatoes and one slice of pickles.
Would have been a lot better with lettuce, actual burger sauce (which I don't know what it was supposed to be. I assume thousand Island dressing) and the pickles would have been great if they were normal sliced pickle chips and more of them. It was like you eat an entire slice (really small slices) and 90% of the pizza there's no pickles. And the lettuce would have really been nice..kind of disappointed especially for the price. Domino's would have been...
Read more