Graeter's Ice Cream — Restaurant in Sharon Township

Pretty good quality ice cream, average size scoops. Limited flavor selection, but the flavors themselves are quite tasty. Their menu separates ice cream into flavors with and without chips, so I was expecting the chips to be special. Not only are they milk chocolate instead of dark, but they're chewy instead of crunchy. I've never had chips like that in ice cream and I never want to again. (The toffee pieces in the toffee ice cream were also not crunchy. I expected a flavor like toffee chip to be full of crunch and it tasted like it was left out...

Out of towner here and visiting for an event. I was told this place has the best ice cream in the area and that is a correct statement ! The most popular flavor is black raspberry chip and it should be called black raspberry chunk because the chocolate pieces were big! But I had the coconut chunk and it was just as good. What’s nice about this place is you can get travel boxes that they pack you with dry ice....

We stopped at this location while passing through Columbus and we are so glad we did. We were greeted by the manager, who was very welcoming and helpful. He let us try a few flavors so we could choose the best one. The salted caramel was yummy and the chocolate chunk has huge pieces of delicious chocolate! The shop is sparkling clean and smells wonderful and there is plenty of seating. Will definitely...