Uptown Slice — Restaurant in Sheboygan

Edit to review 10 months ago! What happened?? Sadly on our return from our summer solstice, we stopped in for a few slices, walked up placed order with partners wife, and wham 3 slices presto boom fast ! Freaking fast! That said I bet the Mrs. She wouldn't walk over to our bench with our order and YOU GUESSED IT! a grunt and a reach across the bar floor our pizza slices were handed! 😂 Lol! So my chicken BBQ sadly where's the chicken?? Hmm, tasted like SWEET BABY RAY'S! Spritzed on to maybe hide the fact maybe 2 chicken pieces maybe?? Maybe been on my slice? Doubtful, next Mrs politely walked up to bar to get her absolutely cold 1 slice of two rewarmed up! We forgot to use our code word toasty to the cook's for us! That said the gal says loud enough for all 4 customers WE CAN'T WARM THIS YOU HAVE A BITE FROM IT!!!! OMG! should of just walked out! so she leaves the pizza slice on the bar WE DON'T WANT IT! Shortly again hands over the bar! Not bringing it out to the bench? A apologie? Anything? Ok Now I really really hate to say this yes Jerry wasn't there? Prices seemed to go up? Slices seem smaller? Lots of staff in kitchen? If you offer no table service please let everyone know! Not a big deal but wtf! If you aren't busy? Put some meat on the pizza bro! You sadly are doomed if you don't fix things! We just came back from Florida! PIZZA BTS JOINT'S that pay rent's of per square ft ' rents $75- $125 a square foot and their pie slices $5.00, $5.75, $6.00 1/3 larger with gourmet toppings! I mean gourmet! I only posted this Jerry to inform you and the public what we experienced! Yes you can't be there 5 days a week! But if you can't maybe cut the hours some more? IMO😁

prior review 10 months back* Amazing! Sheboygan has a true pizzeria! It's all about the dough! This place was recommended by my wife's executive chef, ok let's try! Sheboygan has so many places that serve so-called pizza! This place nails it! Had margarita - perfection,:) wife's had several different slices,, perfect! Spoke with the owner,, great pizza...

The food is good…when it’s actually hot and fresh however I ordered from them several times and there’s been too many issues with their service to give them a good rating. The first time ordering from them was a good experience, the pizza was hot and although it looked like the pizza slid to one side and got smushed when I was bringing it home all & all it was a good experience. Sadly every time after that has been subpar or worst. My orders were never ready at the time listed for pickup. One time they didn’t even make the pizza at all and offered me a free slice as compensation but said it would take 20+ minutes to make my order (mind you I had hungry kids in the car) so I declined and asked for a refund which took 5 days before it returned to my bank account. I gave them one last chance this past weekend and I arrived exactly at the time scheduled and this time the pizza was cold almost like it had been on the counter for a while. It literally felt like I was eating a day old pizza. I don’t think I’ll ever order from them again and definitely wouldn’t recommend it given...

(Update below)

My husband has spent a lot of time in NY since he was little, & we have forever been on a quest to find a pizza place that can compete with a NY slice (in NE, WI & elsewhere). Today, we found it! Omg was it good! ❤️ We will definitely be regulars, as no other pizza can compare! The crust had the perfect crunch & texture, big slices that can be folded & devoured, delicious sauce, cheese & toppings. The red peppers were so good too! We had the cheese & meatball parm.... I would get either one again. Turamisu was so good too! I've already had a slice for breakfast, & another for lunch. Yum!

UPDATE: We have been back 6 more times (from Chilton) since this post was written one month ago. ❤️ IT IS SOOOOOO GOOD! We've tried numerous single slices, & have bought about 6 full-sized cheese & a couple with the hot peppers to take back to the kids. There has been nothing we don't love! Desserts are super delicious, and The Three Sheep's Cream Ale is one of our favorites to drink, & I really enjoyed the chicken sweet pepper vodka sauce slice tonight! My new...