Fresh Mozzarella Pizza — Restaurant in Simsbury

I promised I'd do a review for the two workers who served me late at night on 1/30. I know the lady was named Paola, I didn't quite catch the gentleman's name. It was late at night, maybe close to 10:00, and I've been craving pizza all day after not having eaten all afternoon/evening. I was going to go home from a rehearsal that was taking place nearby and luckily this was the only nearby pizza place that was open that served slices. I've been imagining the perfect slice all night and I've been given just that. The slices were big, I didn't think I'd eat them both, but I did and they were the best slices ever. Not greasy, crispy, and delicious! I got one cheese and the other peppers, mushrooms, and onions. Both employees were kind and respectful and was starting to clean up to close the restaurant. I was a satisfied customer and will be coming back again soon. I wish I can go all the time but I live all the way in New Britain, but overall when ever I have a show nearby and I'm craving pizza, I know where to...

Ordered 3 dinners and only received 2. When I called I was rudely told that I did not order 3 and I was confused, yet my receipt for $85 says I did. The first dinner was the Chicken Alfredo (17.99), it was MAYBE one piece of chicken cut into strips and spaghetti pasta with a spoonful of sauce. My father-in-law said it looks like an item off a kids menu. The second was their Seafood Combo (15.95), the ONE piece of fish was decent and medium size, but did not make up for the TWO pieces of shrimp or the missing scallops. It comes with a TON of fries though so you have to dig for your handful of tiny fried clams. Can’t comment on the third dinner, Stuffed Shells (15.99) because we did not receive it, so I had the side salad for dinner. Carrot cake was good but the chocolate cake was freezer burn to hell and tasted like styrofoam. Every one star comment on this restaurant is true; tasteless food, missing items, rude staff- do yourself a favor and order from one of the thousand other restaurants...

Five stars isn’t enough!! Fresh Mozzarella Pizza is hands-down one of the best pizza places in the area. My husband and I were in town for paramotor training and ended up coming back here almost every single day. We tried nearly every specialty pizza they offer, and each one was better than the last.

Their fresh mozzarella (true to their name) is out of this world—the sauce is rich and flavorful, the cheese is fresh and melty, and the crust is that perfect crispy-yet-chewy texture that real pizza lovers look for. You can tell they care about quality, and it shows in every bite.

But what really made the experience unforgettable was the owner. He went out of his way to take care of us—genuinely kind, welcoming, and clearly passionate about what he does. It wasn’t just good food; it was hospitality at its finest.

If you’re anywhere near this place, do yourself a favor and go. Fresh Mozzarella Pizza isn’t just a great meal—it’s a place that makes you feel...