El Pollito Pio Ice Cream Shop + More — Restaurant in Sun Prairie

Great food, friendly people, delicious ice cream, relaxed but upbeat vibe, open late... what more could you ask! Excited to see this place open, and looking forward to coming back.

The banana pudding ice cream opened my eyes to a whole new world of possibilities. It's not just banana ice cream with wafers in it, it's pudding ice cream, so the texture is way creamier (like custard but moreso) and the flavor is super rich. That stuff alone is worth coming here for. We also had burritos- my partner was so-so on his, but my steak burrito was honestly perfect. Probably just a matter of preference and/or protein choice. We both agree their green sauce is fantastic though, and wished we had more.

They haven't been open long, so the inside is still a work-in-progress. But I love the vibrant colors and music, and they aren't lacking a thing in the flavor department. Definitely recommend giving El...

Food was horrible. I would not recommend. Order corn for my daughter and kernels were dark brown bruised and did not taste fresh. You can visually see and tell corn was either leftover and old. Steak tacos was bad, was there not a single effort made into this? The meat was tasteless! Looked broiled on a pan and season with salt and black pepper. Birria tacos... the juice and red pepper was sooooo watered down. Yes the meat was tender but again it was tasteless. Food is bland, choppy and poorly made. I regret wasting my money here. Please season your meat. Also ordered a steak burrito yet to be tried, but we have no hope for their food at this point. Will never go back and is the worst...

Not sure if it was just an off day for the restaurant but unfortunately, I wasn’t a fan of the tacos. The steak and chicken tacos I had were dry and the steak meat tasted of black pepper only. The taco sauce lacked flavor also. Overall, just underwhelming tacos that I can’t recommend to anyone really. With the number of taco restaurants around town, this one is a pass for me.

Owners seemed really nice though so I hope the best for them. Hopefully, they can make improvements on their tacos because I would love to support a small,...