Miseno Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Babylon

Food is just outstanding here. Literally everything I've ever had has been great. I had their vodka sauce recently on a chicken parm hero, my goodness it was delicious. Probably the best vodka sauce I've had.

I told my Mom about this place, who is a recent resident of Deer Park. She's had a bunch of stuff, all great, but the other day she had an eggplant parm hero and pasta with pesto, and she said it was among the best she has ever eaten in her life. She's nearly 80 and Italian is one of her favorite styles of food to eat, so that review of hers comes from a place of true understanding. I got my wife a vegetable calzone the other day, and she ate the second half after saying she would save it for the next day.

Sometimes I need a protein on my pizza and I'm not always down for sausage or meatball, , so I'll get a buffalo chicken from time to time. It's just perfect. Their deep dish chicken parm is also great. They do deep dish here really well too, a gem of this place outside of Chicago.

As far as size, it's a typical local pizza place. They have a few tables for eating in. The place is always clean. The staff is always trained well and helpful.

Their pizza is how pizza should be: "well done". There is no flop to it. It's not "raw" like many Long Island places are. If you want it that way, they'll do it for you, you just have to ask for it.

Just excellent food. It is just 5 mins from where I live, but I'd come here even if I lived further away.

I always try and say what a place could do better, but I'm struggling here. I've been on a stromboli kick lately, and they don't offer those here (but I haven't asked) but that's a Philly thing so I don't expect it here.

Go here, get a few pies. Get the chicken francese. Get the pesto. Get the meatballs. Get penne ala vodka. You're really not going to miss.

Signed, A fat guy who...

After being a loyal customer to the old Deer Hills pizza, I decided to try Miseno since the location is convenient, and it was a newer business. I decided to order on the Slice app, which is easier for payment and knowing your order will be fulfilled accurately since you’re the person placing your order. I ordered two slices- one buffalo, one white. I went to go pickup my order, they asked me the name, handed me the box and said “Have a great night”! I then drove home, opened the box, to find ONE slice of pizza in there. Now, my family member was out of a dinner, that I paid full price for. I figured they just messed up and forgot it, so I drove all the way back to Miseno with the pizza box and said: “Hey, you forgot my buffalo slice”. The young girl tells me at the counter, “Oh, we didn’t have it so we refunded you for it”. I am happy they refunded me for it, but wouldn’t you think you should tell the customer BEFORE they leave that there’s going to be an item missing? I would’ve picked something else out for the same price! So now I wasted my time, gas, and money! Instead of saying, “Have a good night”- couldn’t the team have said: “Hey, just want to let you know, we don’t have the buffalo available right now, but would you like something else for the same price or a refund?”, which at least informs me I am missing an item. I will never go back to Miseno. The communication for their customers really blew my mind; I was shocked that this happened. I’ll happily go elsewhere that’s able to...

Ok so here goes, I waited 25 minutes for 2 Missenos salad and dozen clams, there were alot of people working there, behind the counter. When the order was ready I looked at the salad and they were not Messino salads they were Cesar Salads!!!! When I placed the order the young man said Cesar salad , I said no messino salad. And a dozen baked clams. So I have to wait another 20 min for Messino salad to be made. I get Messino Salad all the time whenever I do get it. Well, I think things are changing there and it’s best to stick to pizza. I hate to say goodbye, but the past 2 months I’ve had another incident with Messino salad. Not getting into old stories. There was a delivery girl there with straight hair she was standing on the side of the pizza oven running her hands through her hair about 5 times and then tied it back with a brown scrunchie. It was gross, go into restroom if you need to fix your hair. THEN WASH YOUR HANDS. You’re working with peoples food orders. I was truly disappointed with Missenos and wish them well. I drive from Ronkonkoma to get your salad but no more. ...