Goldberg's Famous Bagels — Restaurant in Town of East Hampton

Before I share my experience, 3 weeks ago I reached out to Goldberg's through their website. Amanda replied and asked for a description of the man who served me but never responded to me after that. The man seemed like the owner or a manager.

I went to the Amagansett location 8/19/2023 and ordered a 1/4lb of cream cheese along with bagels, etc. The man who was taking my order put a container on the scale and began to fill it with cream cheese but knocked the container on the floor. A lot of the cream cheese came out on the floor. He picked the container up and put it back on the scale and continued to fill it back up with cream cheese. I asked him if it fell on the floor and he responded, in an aggravated tone, yes but the cream cheese in the container didn't touch the floor. I asked if he could please give me a new one and he rolled his eyes and started again. I thanked him but he wouldn't look at...

Goldberg loves bacon! Not kosher or halal. Good everything bagel. Toasted to a crispy bite. Bacon cooked well. Eggs were fluffy fried. Cheese well melted. BEC porportions were just right. A bit too much ketcup. Service could have b3en friendlier. Topped off the meal with a large ice coffee. Came out to over 16. Not sure how but ok. I still may come back.

Stopped by again last weekend of summer 2025. Was staying at hither hills campground and going fishing at 8am that day. Wanted to start the morning off early with a fresh bagel and ice coffee. They open at 6am and we got there around 620. They didn’t have bagels yet. The guy behind the counter couldn’t say when they would get their bagel delivery, “ could be in 10 minutes, could be twenty,” he exclaimed. :( Bae was disappointed and I was a little too. I settled with a bacon egg and cheese or …. A roll. Ate it...

They don't make the bagels there, they ship fresh bagels daily from Southampton? They have a limited selection. Must use temp summer staff, I was one of 2 people in a store with three employees. The other person was being helped and took forever just to place an order, you can tell it was like his first day there.

I would compare the bagel somewhere between stale bread, petrified wood, a deadly weapon, a pool ring toss game, a Frisbee with a hole in the middle, a spare tire for a shopping cart, (please comment any suggestions you may have, I think you get the idea)

It's a modern day Bagelastrophy

I will say, other Goldbergs I've been to are fine. My advice, skip this one, even if it means you don't eat that day, you'll thank me.

Montauk Goldbergs, you have been...