3 Boys From Italy — Restaurant in Town of Haverstraw

About two years ago during COVID lockdown, we decided to try and find the best pizzeria in the area and support local eateries that were struggling to stay afloat we came to three boys and found the pizza was delicious. We had finally found a pizzeria ! Well, that was short lived . The past 4 months the pizza has gone waaaay down hill, and the food as well. Seems like instead of three boys from Italy its now one boy from italy and two boys from oshkosh . The cook must have quit and the new guy has no clue what hes doing. My daughter picked up some chicken parm hero’s and the chicken was way overcooked , almost burnt, then they threw it on some bread with cheese and overheated it.It was dry and inedible. We also got a chicken parm pie and they forgot to put the tomato sauce on it!! We picked up a margarita slice and it was basically a slice of dough with sauce and a piece of packaged sliced mozzarella cheese from shop rite thrown on it then micro-waved to melt the cheese. It was disgusting I threw it away. Just when I thought it couldn't get worse, my nephew ordered a pie -half pepperoni half cheese. When he got home , the pizzeria had cut and pasted random slices together to create a pie and then threw some pepperoni on it and sold it as if it was a fresh pie. Its un- fortunate they have gone down in quality cuz the owner is a nice guy , very welcoming but his food sucks. Never going back there. The one star was...

Just had the worst experience ever. I’ve been a customer of 3 boys for 3 years now and I’m sad to say that tonight’s situation has cost them my business. I order a pie online. I got an email from the company used to place their online orders, Slice, saying the order wasn’t able to be processed by the pizzeria. I asked if it had anything to do with my card used to pay and they said “no, the restaurant didn’t accept your order.” I called 3 boys to inquire about what happened an the incompetent manager answered the phone. He abruptly told us he “didn’t get our order” and left it at that. When we asked how to get our money back, he rudely replied “that has nothing to do with us.” He then continued to try to talk over me as I explained to the “manager” that as the customer, I’m asking for assistance and what was he going to do about it. It was then that he finally gave me the phone number to Slice. He then told me “calm down sweetie” which made me even more mad. Never...

I just recently visited 3 Boys From Italy and had an amazing dining experience. When looking for plant-based options, we came across the arugula pizza which definitely caught our attention. Let me tell you, it was superb! The pizza was incredibly fresh and authentic, with every bite bursting with flavor. We also ordered the garlic knots, and they were simply irresistible - soft, tasty, and perfect for dipping in their hearty marinara sauce.

What truly set this establishment apart was the exceptional service provided by the owner and his daughter. They went above and beyond to ensure that we had a memorable dining experience. Their attentiveness and friendly attitude made us feel right at home.

Overall I highly recommend trying 3 Boys From Italy for yourself. It's a local establishment that delivers top-notch quality and hospitality. If you're looking for delicious pizza and a warm atmosphere, this is the place to be. We will...