Bagel Boys — Restaurant in Town of Hempstead

My father had stage 4 pancreatic cancer and had a difficult time eating. My father asked me to get him a sesame bagel with lox spread. My father waited in the car as I went in to get his bagel. Keep in mind my father at that time did not eat anything for 2 days before that because of the tremendous pain that would occur after eating certain foods due to the cancer. I brought the bagel to my father in the car, and he saw the lox spread was orange (which isn't bad) but he thought it should have been white, and it also had a foul smell. He asked me to bring it back in. When I brought it back, the manager said to me "I know your father. Call him and put it on speaker." I then called my father. On the phone the manager was explaining to him that the lox spread is good and he should try it, but my father simply didn't want to try it, as people with pancreatic cancer experience nausea and the look and smell of the lox spread made him nauseous. He asked for a sesame bagel with egg salad instead. The manager was so frustrated after throwing out a bagel that probably cost him a dollar at most to make. He then said to me "I would kill your father if it wasn't for the cancer that would kill him first." What kind of human being says such a thing? He should be ashamed of himself and anyone with common sense would know not to say such a thing. Whoever reads this and thinks of going there, think about this story before making that decision. I am now mourning the loss of my...

We needed to cater in Breakfast for our Breakfast Connect Membership Drive that was held on January 8th, 2025 in the Hewlett Fire Department Ballroom. One of our members, Rosalie recommended Bagel Boys in Cedarhurst. We sat down with the very nice owner who was extremely accommodating and personable. He worked out a great deal for us and stayed within our budget. I was assured that the breakfast would be ready for pickup at 7am. As I drove up to Bagel Boys window, I saw everything nicely laid out at 6:50am, ahead of time. Even though he offered free delivery, I chose to pick it up. I walked in and was happy to see the owner and his crew bring the entire spread along with coffee out to my car. Everyone at the event enjoyed the breakfast. It was really great food! They did an amazing job. I am going back to Bagel Boys for our next event in the Spring. If you want quality, quantity and great food from a friendly business owner, I strongly recommend Bagel Boys on Central Avenue in Cedarhurst. Their catering is...

I wanna start off by recommending the german chocolate cake coffee. Out of this world!

I know the owner personally. He is an extraordinary individual! But I can easily tell you to put that aside and assure you that I would choose this specific bagel shop over any others in the Tri-state area. Especially if you're going kosher! After all, bagels are and originated from the Jewish culture. The shop is run well and you can be guaranteed the highest quality and freshest food on the market! I wish I could give you one specific favorite dish. It's difficult because it's all really good. I hung out there on one particular night, but I specifically went back and ate there to truly ensure that it's the same quality, It has always been. This review is up-to-date.

The pastries are phenomenal as well!

I recommend pretty much anything on the menu, but if coffee is something you enjoy, you absolutely must check out this specific one I recommended in...