Jonny D's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Huntington

This rating is only to reflect on the service of the manager Kayla. Her attitude was not becoming as one who should be managing a food service establishment. I asked for my family and I to be moved to another table because of limited room of the table. She informed me that the only reason she gave us another table was because the next seating was a party of two and the small table would be fine for them. She went out of her way to advise me it was not because I asked her or that she could care at all that we had enough room for our food at the table. My husband biscuit and gravy came out cold and he ordered additional food not to complain. Kayla came over to the table and asked if he wanted her to heat up the order. No apologies, or anything. and who want someone to stick their food in the microwave rather than asking if he wanted her to redo the order. Someone need to tell her about Customer Service and send her back through training. Our waitress was Awesome. Other than the manager the restaurant was a thumbs up. Will find if Kayla is there before eating...

After not having a slice here in years, maybe even since 2017... They absolutely knocked it outta the park!! I'm super impressed!

The last time I had eaten here, they still had a bar across the window. Since their renovations, the interior is sleek, eye-catching, and reveals a bit of the history about New York, Huntington, and even the establishment itself. Very nice, great conversation starter while waiting to chow down.

As for the slices themselves, I had ordered a mushroom slice, as per family tradition. The crust had a wonderful crunch to it, which contrasted nicely to the generous amount of cheese. It's truly an intense love affair; slightly messy, incredibly satisfying, and a meal that demands to be enjoyed heartily from the very first bite.

Some may find it overwhelming, but it's a slice that left me wishing I bought the pie. A wonderful balance, the kind of slice you see on the movie screens. If you're considering yourself a loyalist of any of the other local pizza joints, give Jonny another shot. Like a fine wine, they only have gotten...

Consistently excellent pizza, with great balance of flavors. The crust is simple but artful – a very thin layer of almost-charred crispiness at bottom, with just a little al dente, yeasty flavored dough, not too thick or chewy, for the sauce and cheese to relax into; and it folds into a good bite without flopping all over the place.

Good pizza is an art. Just think of how important it is that the sauce and the cheese hang onto the crust just in the right degree so it doesn’t all fall apart, and that the crust isn’t just a bunch of dough, but gives you all that great texture which makes you look forward to the next bite. I had the good fortune to grow up with great classic New York slices, and Jonny D’s just nails it, closer than any place else on Long Island I’ve discovered in the last 20 years.

I’ve never had a bad pizza here, and they’ve always been the way...