Crispino's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Islip

Stopped in for a slice of sicilian with my son, as it is his proffered slice, a quick search lead us back here. We'd been here before, after a few of my daughter's activities - always meant to leave a review. He got his 2 sicilian slices, I got one too - but, couldn't resist trying one of their specialty slices - a sausage and peppers (one of my favorite dishes) slice. I'd had one before, elsewhere - we won't talk about that much. This sausage and peppers slice was near perfection! Not soggy, in fact, quite crispy - but, definitely not lacking in the signature oil blend that makes sausage and peppers a personal favorite. The topping coverage was entirely, but not overwhelming to the point of taking over the pizza - personally perfect. The sicilian slices - my son ranked higher than his personal favorite spot, which is a HUGE response from him - as he enjoyed the balance of crunchy and "squishy" as he calls the doughy topside of a sicilian slice. I have to agree, really top notch!...

I don’t know what’s going on with this place but ever since ownership change, it’s been totally off. The pizza I ordered was old and tasted horrible. My nephew gave it a 5.8 out of 10. The chicken parm, once something I would travel to get, is totally different. Basically chewy chicken, not cooked to order, and the sauce tastes totally different. Obviously they have went with a different vendor or provider, or different cook? Truly a disappointing experience and this was with me giving them the benefit of the doubt because last time I went it was off as well. I’m hoping this is a wake up call and they get back to where they are, but, being they can’t even get a simple order cooked to order, I’m sure...

Ordered online to save time wanted to pay cash in store when I got into the store it was three dollars more to pay cash in the store. Meanwhile, I had a receipt telling me how much it was and the owner would not give it to me for the price of the receipt that I had. That is the receipt I had and they would not honor it. They charged me three dollars more than what this receipt said so I do not recommend eating here and if you wanna order online, make sure you pay online because they rip you off when you’re in the store horrible customer service by the owner who was completely in the wrong. I had a receipt for what I was supposed to pay and they charged me more just...