Subway - Islandia - 54406 — Restaurant in Town of Islip

I've gone to this location a lot. There are a couple great employees, but some of them are really terrible-- the awful ones are the ones that caused all the bad experiences I've had here naturally. Today was the final straw. I ordered a sub online for pickup. I specifically selected "Less" (light) for the honeymustard option. When I opened my sandwich to eat it, the entire thing was completely saturated in honey mustard. It's to the point where this depressing sandwich barely even qualifies as edible. It's soggy, honey mustard is gushing from every direction, spilling all over the wrapper, my hands-- a tiny bit even got on my dress. It's as if I ordered honey mustard with a side of sandwich. I also paid an extra $1.25 for avocado, and there's barely any on here. It looks like they might have added mayo I didn't ask for, although it may just be the cheese melting from the heat today-- frankly I can't tell whether there's cheese on here at all cause all I taste and see is honey mustard. It looks like they might have excluded the cheese, and they definitely did not toast the bread. I was hoping for a balanced lunch and all I got was condiment. A previous time at this location while trying to order in person, the employees kept snickering at customers including myself for reasons unbeknownst to me. The careless employees here make me feel like it's no longer worth coming here and spending money. It's rare that I feel inclined to write a negative review but it was warranted after several incidents like this. TL;DR - don't go here if you have another subway/sandwich shop option nearby. There's a good chance you'll get the poor employees that don't care, give you a pathetic looking sandwich, and sometimes laugh at people...

I walked in at 9:03 and was told that the location was closed despite the online website saying 9:30 & even outside on the door saying 9:30. They said the manager is supposed to change the times but never did. Manager should change the times so that customers don’t waste their time and drive to...

I often go to the subway in Islandia, NY. There is a gentleman that works there Yatin. He is the nicest, friendliest person ever! I feel like he is always there & always in a happy & cheerful mood. He also makes great sandwiches. Subway is lucky to have such a...