Giovanni's pizza — Restaurant in Town of Orangetown

1st time we had the pizza - whole family got diarrhea. It tasted terrible and very oily. Threw most of it out.

2nd time (decided to give it another try). Very oily and didn't taste good.

3rd time... Yes, gave it another try. Very oily and still tasted bad.

4th time. Got ice cream from louies next door and after decided to get a slice. Guy didn't put it in oven to heat up.. . He gave me the slice which was warm and overcooked somewhat burnt... Guess this was the reason he didn't put the slice in the oven to heat up. The slice again was very oily and not good tasting.

I am so confused by all these high star reviews for this place.

I feel bad cause I want to like this pizza, but just can't. I gave it 4 tries and it was...

I cold called Giovanna's while in the area shopping for pizza. I hit them with the usual questions while pizza shopping. The guy who answered the phone responded to my questions as if I were a jerky boy trying to pull a prank.

To his surprise I arrived a brief moment after we hung up. I bought 8 individual slices and chow to dine in. The place was decorated really nicely and they had a Christmas tree! The pizza was overall good. The crust was more crispy than usual pizza but not enough to make a stink.

There were drones outside which made me extremely nervous during my...

Fantastic! Pizza was fresh and hot and tasted amazing. We got pepperoni and Margherita pizza. This place seems to care about all the little details, like keeping the parmesan shakers in the fridge and putting the pizzas on elevated stands so it doesn’t take up table room. The service was incredible. I went with a large group and we had planned for one person to pay for everything and we would figure it out later for paying that person back. Giovanni’s offered the option to pay individually even though we didn’t ask and even though it...