Chris & Tony’s — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

Welcome to Chris and Tony’s, where the family isn’t just on the menu – it is the menu! This delightful Italian eatery will have you feeling like you’ve just been adopted into the famiglia. Every dish tells a story, and let me tell you, the Chicken alla Ariana is one epic tale of flavor!

As someone named Arianna, I couldn't resist trying a dish named after such a special family relative of the owners. And guess what? I had the incredible fortune of meeting the Ariana herself, who graced us with her presence and a slice of her heavenly homemade carrot cake. Imagine the best carrot cake you’ve ever had, then double it. It was moist, nutty (with just the right amount of walnuts), and drizzled with caramel that could make an angel weep. The icing was a revelation – light, airy, and not too sweet, achieving the perfect balance with the cake. If you ever doubted that perfection exists, this carrot cake is all the proof you need.

But the magic of Chris and Tony’s doesn’t end with the food. The real charm lies in the people. Lil Chris runs the show with a level of customer service that makes you feel like a treasured guest at a family reunion. His crew mirrors his dedication, ensuring every visit is a delightful experience. Special shoutout to Gianna, the bartender extraordinaire. Not only is she a knockout, but her cocktail game is strong enough to turn any ordinary night into a celebration.

Chris and Tony’s is not just a restaurant; it’s a place where you come to be part of something bigger. So, gather your loved ones and head over to this cozy spot. After all, if the family is on the menu, you know it’s got to be good. Can't wait to bring my family back for another round of love, laughter, and mouthwatering meals!

P.S. Want more of Ariana’s life-changing treats? Follow her on Instagram – your taste buds will thank you!...

Hubby and I came here for dinner. I heard about this restaurant from Hubby, so I wanted to try it. We made a reservation just in case. Jace took our reservation, and luckily he was our server for the night too. He’s excellent! The way the crew worked together at this restaurant was fantastic. Once escorted to the table, they’re ready with water and bread. Everything is synchronized and organized. The restaurant is spacious and beautifully decorated. Perfect table space so we don’t hear our neighbors’ secrets. The better dining experience here than in the city, for sure.

Jace made a nice menu intro. After the opening (like watching Opera), we ordered Zuppa di clams as an appetizer. My entree was shrimp Luciano over spinach. Hubby had the 1/2 Chris & Tony's Chicken. Unique dishes, mine and Hubby’s! I loved the vegetables used for both entrees. My plate was excellent! Spinach and shrimp were cooked perfectly. Hubby’s dish was served with a few veggies, and I kept taking his broccoli, lol! While dining, the manager, Craig, came by to ensure we got our meals correctly and that we liked it. Are you kidding me? We loved it! This was one of our best date nights. I still remember the taste of my shrimp entree. It was too delicious to forget. Of course we had some dessert too! Decaf cappuccino and tiramisu, woohoo!

One of the owners, Chris, was there working hard too. He welcomed us and all the guests at the entrance. I give him credit for training his team perfectly. Best meals, gorgeous restaurant and excellent service and teamwork. Highly...

Chris and Tony’s is the proof that do come true! Celebrating my mother’s 80th birthday at Chris and Tony’s was the best decision my family could have made. This is the most perfect restaurant for ALL celebrations. From the moment we walked into the restaurant and they had our table ready; every single detail IN BETWEEN from start to finish was awesome…THEY COULD NOT HAVE BEEN MORE ACCOMMODATING!!! From management to our amazing waiter, Vinny…This experience was sensational. Not only was the food delicious, plentiful, and fresh, but this was the best service we have ever experienced at any restaurant we have ever been to. All of our dishes were so good, Champaign toast…perfect, water glasses continuously refilled, bread basket never empty, all requests taken care of with so much love and and care…IT WAS EVERYTHING YOU COULD IMAGINE AND MORE!

This staff cares as much as you do about the memories created for your celebration. In every single part of our dining experience it was so apparent how much effort and dedication the Chris and Tony’s staff puts into ensuring your special occasion is exactly what it should be; there is nothing quite more important than family time AND THEY “get it”... I highly recommend planning for your next important life event to take place at this fine restaurant. Make your reservation and have Chris and Tony’s play it out...