Elise's Niece's Cafe — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

I absolutely love that I found this place! I ordered a pistachio cake with no sugar in the icing for my dad’s birthday and they absolutely delivered in making the best birthday cake I could have ever asked for! It was really nice that they were able to accommodate that I wanted no sugar in the icing since I thought the cake was too sweet with sugar in both the icing and the cake and I also loved the little birthday banner that they added to the cake to make it festive. I really enjoy the snowball cookies as they pair really well with tea or coffee. During my first visit the staff member was so sweet and she gave me a snowball cookie to try for free! I do wish the coffee had more variety but since they don’t have an expresso machine it’s hard to make a lot of drinks and I wasn’t the biggest fan of the caramel crack, but the honey bee coffee was really nice and I’d recommend that over the crack coffees. I love the aesthetic of the area as well and I can’t wait to try more things from them! TLDR: pistachio cake and snowball cookies are amazing and they will make items with less sugar if you ask. Wish there was more variety for the coffee but the honey bee is pretty good and I didn’t like the caramel crack coffee. Staff is amazing and the atmosphere is so...

This cafe, tucked away in the back of a charming thrift shop, offers a unique and creative concept with a menu that frequently changes. The decor is cute and cozy, making it a pleasant spot to relax. However, the food didn’t quite meet expectations. The croissant cookie was enjoyable, but the snowball and dulce de leche cookies were disappointingly dry. The caramel crack coffee was fun to crack open, but the artificial caramel syrup flavor overshadowed any potential richness. We also took home a coconut cake and a brownie. While the cake was passable, it suffered from an artificial coconut taste. The brownie, however, was particularly disappointing—burnt in parts, crumbly, and lacking the rich chocolate flavor one would expect. Boxed brownies often surpass this quality, and homemade versions would likely be far superior. Though the cafe's cakes might be worth trying in the future due to their intriguing flavors, I’d steer clear of their displayed desserts based...

An incredibly cozy and welcoming family-run cafe & bakery with a back courtyard.

From the moment you walk into the modern-classic farmhouse feeling space, you're welcomed by the delicious smell of baked goods and incredibly friendly staff. They're seriously some of the best service folks I've run into, and really made me feel at home.

The display case is full of delicious treats, all made fresh right in the back by the staff. They constantly try out and make new ones, and the prices are all very reasonable. The Rainbow Cookie was one of the best I've ever had, and the Cherry Coffee Cookie was super creative and fantastic.

They do events in the back, and there's a fire pit and a bar. it's also connected to a wonderful antique & home goods shop.

It's such a great family business and an absolute must place to stop in and hang...