Mario's — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

My parents and I recently moved to Nashville, TN and I usaully don’t leave reviews, but I have been craving Mario’s like crazy. I remember coming to the family-owned restaurant ever since I was a little kid and have never been disappointed. My absolute favorite pizza in the whole world is the grandma slice. Fresh tomatoes, parm, and an awesome crust. Also love the fried zuc, riceballs, rigatoni florentina, penne ala mario, ziti pizza, and volka pasta with prosciutto. Can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. This place is constantly mentioned in my family, even though it has been a while since we have moved. Note: take the negative reviews with a grain of salt. Even though located in NY, some people aren’t used to traditional (semi) sweet marinara that you get from freshly...

We have been getting take-out from Mario's for quite a while, but last weekend was the first time we dined in. It was on Father's Day. All I can say is if you haven't eaten there, you don't know what you are missing. The dining room was clean and the tables are spread out to give all of their guest ample room to enjoy their meal. The restroom was also spotless! Now- the most important part--- The food was outstanding!!! Everything on the menu looked so great- I had a tough time deciding on what to select. We will definitely be going back again - very soon. I also plan to cater a graduation party from Mario's. I know that I wont be disappointed. Oh- one more thing- they have the BEST ALA VODKA SAUCE I have...

In the midst of a very difficult weekend after our bridal salon experienced a fire, the incredible team at Mario’s in Massapequa went above and beyond to support us. They generously delivered pizza, pasta, salad, heros, and more to help keep our staff fueled as we navigated the chaos. As a fellow family-owned business, their kindness and generosity truly touched our hearts. It's moments like these that remind us how special our community is. We are so grateful for Mario’s and will absolutely continue to support and order from them moving forward. Thank you for showing up when it mattered most — your food was amazing and your hearts even bigger.

Roselynn, Anthony, Cristina, and our team at...