Lenny's Pizza & Bistro (AKA Lenny's of Jamesport) — Restaurant in Town of Riverhead

6/14/25 Once again, Lenny’s comes through with a delicious and amazing dinner. Debbie our waitress made this a fun evening of chat and dining. She took great care of us.

Let’s start by saying that have the best bread on Long Island, made on site!!!!! And they give you plenty of it!!!!

I ordered the veal parm dinner with a side of linguini marinara. The veal was delicious tender and fried just right. You could cut it with a fork. My wife had the Fettuccini Supreme, fettuccini with portobello, sun dried tomatoes and shrimp in a garlic pesto sauce, it was so delicious!!!!!!!!

We always have an amazing dining experience at Lennys!

8/6/23 Another awesome dinner at Lennys! This place is really awesome with their food, hospitality and prices.

Tonight we ordered mozzarella sticks which were hot and crisp served with a vodka sauce. I decided to go with something different than my usual Veal Parm (which is always great at &Lenny’s) and I got the Rigatoni Bolognese. It was delicious and a very large portion too! We also ordered the eggplant parm which was enjoyed by my wife and daughter and an order of fettuccini Alfredo which was hot and creamy!

Lenny’s always comes through with an excellent dinner. *+++++++

Tonight we came across a really fine Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Ronnie our waitress was so amazing and helpful. She took great care of us and her service was great.

Tonight I had the veal cardinale was amazing. It is a break cutlet in a marsala reduction, mozzarella, prosciutto and shallots. It was so delicious and a very generous portion, served with a side of pasta. Delicious!

My wife had the chicken francaise which she enjoyed as well. Both orders were generous and served with their fresh Italian bread.

I highly recommend Lenny's. Their food is amazing, delicious...

This review is a year in the making. On July 25, 2018 my Wife, my Daughters and I were exploring Long Island New York as we celebrated our 26th Wedding Anniversary.

Ron S at Jamesport Vineyard recommended Lenny’s as the best slice around. Now, we grew up near Chicago so there are some preconceived notions towards New York style pizza but we were hungry and had to try it.

Ronnie our waitress made us feel at home from the time we were seated. This is a unique restaurant with a stunning dining room and bar on one side and a casual hang out place on the other.

Ronnie explained that the owner and our chef that night was a former baker and took great pride in the product he puts on your table.

We couldn’t agree more!

What we thought was going to be a Mom and Pop pizza experience far exceeded expectations. It was a fine dining experience that was unexpected. The food placed upon our table was fabulous. From the very fresh ingredients to that top shelf sauce to the crust it all rested on. Oh, that crust. My mouth is watering as I write this just thinking about it.

We apologize to the fine folks at Lenny’s for taking so long to share this review. We recently celebrated our 27th Wedding Anniversary and still reminisce about that day in Jamesport. It’s long overdue but thank you Ronnie for the hospitality and sharing the owners passion with us.

We highly recommend you discover for yourself this delicious, one of a kind,...

NOT recommended. I paid 27 dollars and some change for an 18" round with 3 toppings. The pizza was greasy(pools of it), the sauce very near tasteless, and just... below average pizza. I ordered it topped with bacon, and I barely got ANY bacon on there and they skimmped on the black olives, too. They don't have hamburger\beef as an option. The service over the phone was not very polite, she sounded like she hated her job and didn't want to be taking my order. Seriously, Pizza Hut is better than this place, and I don't even like Pizza Hut that much. I will not be ordering here ever again or recommending it to anyone. Ordered this pizza on May 30, 2014 near 6pm. I suggest you place your order somewhere else. Sorry, folks. A terrible disappointment as my first NY pizza experience. I feel bad for dissing the place. Everyone seems to think Lenny is a nice guy with good pizza. The only in charge looking guy I saw there was arguing with another cook and looked very displeased. :( I came to this place because of the good reviews. Guess I shouldn't trust...