OIP-Original Italian Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Salina

After Toss N Fire delivered my order to the wrong house I thought I’d swing in here and give them one last shot as my last experience here was also horrible, hence why I tried toss n fire this time.

Long story short there was an entire Large pepperoni pizza ready to go in the slices section. I very specifically asked “can I have that whole pizza and is the same as buying a large?” The girl tells me yes and then proceeds to put it in a box. A completely different girl comes up to the counter and asks if I’m all set. I say “I just need to pay for the large pepperoni she’s boxing up”

She responds “well you know I have to charge you per slice for that “ I said “why, she already told me it’s the same as a large pepperoni”

The random girl responds “well it’s meant for slices so I’ll have to charge you for every slice”

I said “alright, see ya later”

Overpriced mediocre food, wings are almost double the cost of every other restaurant in the area and aren’t any better.

Want to over charge their customers any possible...

This is usually a go to place when we are in mattydale I don’t know what that HELL was wrong tonite first of all no lie I was extremely tailgated by an OIP driver all the way down Brewerton Road until we turned into OIP. a young kid in a very old Cadillac with a OIP sign on top , we get inside the place was very crowded hot and chaotic. None of the pizza slices looked appealing at all however, my nine-year-old selected the pepperoni. I could not pick any of them so I opted for a meatball sub. I waited 20 minutes for a meatball sub that has been cooking all day. That ended up tasting like meatballs No sauce and 2 pounds of cheese on top the people behind the counter or none of the ones that I recognize they all were confused and trying to be a boss. I actually made a friend while I was waiting for our food that she ordered 30 minutes prior. I am so disappointed in this place right now, I’m not sure if I will ever return and it’s pretty messed up because this is one of my...

let me just say I'm from New York City but I make my home here in Syracuse and I love love oip they are the closest to New York City pizza the wings are absolutely delicious and the pies are great! I happen to be in the neighborhood of mattydale and I called in for chicken wings and two slices I asked the girl that took the phone call give me a slice with extra cheese and one with pepperoni she say she cannot do extra cheese I say why not ,we don't do extra cheese ,since when because all the other oip in Syracuse I have no problem adding extra cheese on my slice, she went on and said that if she does that she could lose her job because the manager doesn't like to put extra cheese, that is ridiculous I tell you that will be the last time I'll go to the oip in Mattydale what pizza shop do not put extra cheese on a slice of pizza they did in Syracuse but not...