Don Jono's — Restaurant in Town of Smithtown

Pretty disappointed about our experience. We ordered a heart shaped pizza for our children. My wife picked it up and it wasn't heart shaped. Usually not a big deal but when you promise your kids something and then they find out it wasn't done, as parents you feel sad when they get upset. We called Don Jono and they said they can do it but for an extra $10. Are you kidding me??? Being a fellow business owner, That is horrible customer service. It wasn't our fault, why should we have to pay $10? Are they that cheap that they can't absorb the cheese, sauce and dough cost? They messed up, so make it right and satisfy a customer. I just think that was handled really wrong. For a local community place, I expect better. We will be going to another place...

I’ve been going to Don Jonos for years. As someone who worked in the city for most of my life, it’s hard to find pizza on Long Island that can compare to city pizza. The pies from Don Jonos are excellent. Great ingredients and a fantastic sauce which, to me, is what makes or breaks a pizza. They make a great thin crust as well that has been my go to for quite a while now. The owner is awesome and makes you feel at home every time you walk in there. Great staff. Nice to have such a great Pizzaria so...

Don Jono’s is my local family pizza spot. Coming from queens I was nervous i would never find a good spot than came this place. The pizza and food all around is amazing and delicious and hands down the best sauce in the area no competition at all. When you step foot in here they greet you with a smile and make you feel like family. For atmosphere, this place is old school no fancy decor no state of the art seating just your old school family pizza shop and that’s why I give this place...