DeMario's Eatery — Restaurant in Town of Sullivan

Tried Demario’s for the time per someone’s suggestion. Upon walking in a customer was telling us how good everything is. The service was great (we only got baked goods and coffee at counter) but the 2 ladies at the counter were helpful and friends. We ordered $2 cinnamon buns and 2 apple crumb cake slices and a chocolate chip cookie for $20. Then we decided on 2 chai teas to go with them ( those were very good) we took our stuff to chittenango falls to eat and I have to say the cream cheese frosting on the cinnamon bun was very good, the cinnamon bun itself wasn’t anything special and was underdone inside. My 2 year old liked his cookie though it was very soft and fell apart as he tried to eat it. We ate the apple cake later on, its appearance looked very underdone, when eating it the topping was excessive and kind of dry. Barely any apple in it. It was alright, my sister loved it when she tried it and my kids thought it was good. My husband and I could do without next time. But I would try and eat there sometime. The food looked very good and I still want to try a half moon, they...

This is a warm and friendly place for a meal and a chat. Orders are taken at the counter with specials that vary according to the day of the week. If you choose to eat in, one of the ladies will bring your food to the table. The homemade quality is immediately obvious. The fries are incredible, i wish i knew how they get to be so crispy on the outside and creamy on the middle. The grilled cheese sandwich is also delicious. They serve homemade soups daily except in the summer (understandable!).

The tables are well-spaced, lots of room to get around, and the noise level is low, making conversation comfortable.

Most importantly: DeMarios offer the BEST half-moon cookies anywhere! If you get nothing else there, you have to get...

We stop for dinner on Wednesday night. This coffee/sandwich shop looked nice and clean, with a fair amount business. Not expecting a lot, my wife found a Cobb salad and I ordered the special, chicken Reggies. It was a fair amount of food. My wife enjoyed her Cobb salad, but mentioned it was a little short on bacon and they should’ve had blue cheese instead of feta. I tried some but wasn’t a fan of the Italian dressing. My chicken Reggies were flavorful but the mystery chicken meat seem to be very processed. I also didn’t like my food being served on plastic to go containers, That’s probably just me. I never really like much of eating off of to...