4 Keeps — Restaurant in Village of Pewaukee

I love this place! It has been great even since it was PIckled Egg. I have no idea what this other reviewer is talking about the bartender I think she's talking about is amazing! She's unique and fun! Super friendly, always smiling and always willing to recommend or make a new fun drink/shot if you ask. The bartenders take time to get to know the customers and have a really great ability to remember names, which makes you feel like you are walking into "Cheers". I love the atmosphere! They have some more food now, which is awesome! I love their garlic bread! The staff has always been attentive to the customers when I go in. I have MANY friends who frequent this bar on a weekly basis for their Thursday night special. I'm so happy this place has remained open, kept the same awesome bartender, and expanded their food menu...surefire ways to keep the customers coming...

Every time we head back to Wisconsin, 4Keeps is a must-stop on our list. They just don’t make Bloody Marys as good where we live now—seriously, we’ve tried, and it’s been a disaster. But at 4Keeps? They know how it’s done! The owner and bartenders treat you like family, and no matter how long we’ve been away, they always make us feel like we never left. It’s a true Wisconsin bar—clean, welcoming, and full of character. Whether you’re in the mood for a perfectly crafted drink or just a great time, this is the spot. They also give back to the community, and if you know me, you know this is super important. 4Keeps lives up to the name—you’ll keep coming back because this...

My wife and I just moved to Pewaukee and today we came in for the first time. It was a busy bar and we were still greeted and served immediately by Becca who was so kind and very attentive to every patron that she was serving. She made our time there very enjoyable. We stayed through the shift change where we met the next bartender was Nikki who was also so wonderful and on top of taking care of everyone. The bartenders are fantastic. 4 Keeps is a great bar and we plan to make it our new home bar and can’t wait to go back! Thank...