Stella's Pizza — Restaurant in Watertown

Since it was sold 6 months ago nothing has tasted the same anyone who says different go see your doctor cuz there's something wrong with your brain and taste buds I've read some of your reviews You're all liars Pizza don't taste the same since he fired the only pizza maker that knew the recipe 2 months ago anyone who states it still tastes the same as a line sack of you know what!!! This new owner sucks he raised the prices and he stingy on the cheese the pepperoni whatever else it was on food he uses half of it if you're lucky again anyone who stays this still tastes the same is brain dead go see your doctor and something wrong with you

Update owner asked me what he can do to make it better? Here's my answer the was a pizza maker there that everyone trusted and liked hire him back!! You know the one the big guy with muscles he looked good in the window and he made pizzas good and everybody trusted him because he made pizzas he didn't play with his cell phone he didn't talk on his cell phone while he was making pizzas and he always washed his hands where some of your new guys are caught wiping their nose with their hands and putting it back in the pizza dough If you don't bring him back you will lose all the old customers and That's no lie I have one more thing to add a friend of mine bought me some pizza this weekend it was a Stella's pizza I threw it out the window it landed in the street a few moments later the neighborhood dog came by took a sniff and urinated on the pizza I'm not the only one with an opinion on how bad their pizza is not even a dog will eat it. Update They brought back a familiar face in the window The guy that everyone likes and trusts to make their pizza finally the owner had a...

Ordered a pepperoni pizza recently and it was nothing like it used to be, before the business was sold around the fall of 2023. Pizza used to be amazing, the best pizza in the area / rivaled anything I’ve had in NYC or Boston.

The pepperoni and the cheese were clearly of inferior quality (Costco or BJs Wholesale?). I was sick to my stomach after only a couple of slices and had to throw the rest of it out, both a first for me in my 10+ years of ordering from Stella's.

The new owners seemed nice (cordial on the phone and in person) and I want them to succeed, but if they don't go back to the old pizza recipe, which I assume they purchased along with the business, I don't think they're going to be in business much longer.

Old Owners: I don't know why you didn't sell or couldn't have sold the business to Mike, your friendly and hard-working former employee, who I assume wouldn't have changed what had been working so well for so many years, but you didn't and here we are.

New Owners: Please change your pizza recipe back to the original. If you can't do that, please sell the...

There is no better pizza on Earth. I would lay down my life for Mr.Stella. The work he has been doing for all of these years is truly spectacular. He is the Tom Brady of pizza store owners. He has been there for me for over thirty years. Growing up in Watertown, I used to hang out at Stella's everyday after school. It was always a safe place for me no matter what. There are so many memories I have of all of the amazing ways that Mr.Stella has helped me over the years. I remember when I was in seventh grade some kids were always harassing me because I never met my father. One day, they cornered me by the pizzeria, and started attacking me. Mr.Stella saw what was happening and rushed out to save me. Later on, after my mom died, he brought his wife and kids to help move me and my six younger siblings move into an apartment he was paying for because the bank took our house. Later on, when my wife's brain cancer was in it's later stages, Mr.Stella watched my daughter, and he was there for me when she passed away. So in conclusion, Stella's is the best pizza place...