Amelia's Pizzeria — Restaurant in West Allis

We had a group of six and had two orders for delivery. They were nice and changed the Canadian bacon for more pepperoni on one order but the driver didn't follow the provided instructions to drop off at the outdoor patio at our hotel and ended up leaving the pizza on a table in a random hallway. They held the first order and waited an additional 30 minutes to deliver it. Then the second order was wrong. One of the pizzas was supposed to have mushrooms added for an additional $3 but no mushrooms. The next pizza was supposed to have jalapeños added but instead res onions were added. Tried calling the store but no one would answer. Not sure what the deal is...

My first experience with Amelia's went like this: Spent a small fortune to give them a try by ordering delivery. Waited and waited in living room, by large front window, 10 feet from front door. Finally, an hour after ordering, on a whim, I opened the front door and found an ice cold, soggy pizza sitting in the snow, in a paper pizza bag. What can I say, I was dumbfounded. Amelia's crept up and abandoned a pizza, in the snow, outside my front door. Why they chose to not actually deliver the pizza, we may never know. Oh well, it is defrosting in the oven right now. What a disappointing experience. Order at...

Ordered delivery - first time trying this pizza. Ordered the 12" "works" and it came in a plain brown box and delivery was very fast. There is a $4.95 dollar delivery charge, along with a $1.49 "Support local fee", and $1.62 tax and $3.00 tip. So roughly 50% is added to the total by having the pizza delivered. $21 dollar pizza = $32.06 delivered. Now that I got that out of the way, the pizza is decent. The cheese is quality and the toppings were fresh. The crust had a good crisp. The Sauce was not as sweet as I am used to, but I liked it. I normally order at another place, but I will definitely try this...