Mileto's Sub Shop and pizza in Newberry — Restaurant in Williamsport

Came up from Florida for visit family in Jersey Shore and wanted a true Cheesesteak sub. In florida they are ok, but not like PA. I asked around and was told to check put Mileto's. BOY WAS I NOT LET DOWN. I think it was the best Cheesesteak I have ever had, besides making them myself. Only issue, I ordered two subs, one for my aunt which was turkey and then mine. I asked for half for her and whole for me. When I paid, I wondered why the total was so low. The girl put mine in as a half. Thank goodness because I was filled up with that half because it was the famous pounder sub I think.

I put 5 stars but definitely the service could be better or shall I say the friendliness. There was no interaction. I went to my car to wait and my aunt and daughter had to use the bathroom. They went in and asked where it was and the person just pointed. I then went back in and my food was done, but the ladies were chatting no one gave it to me. The cook ended up handing it to me. Besides this the food was great, but definetly did not feel the...

Ordered half a turkey hoagie, with bacon, Swiss cheese and green peppers, got turkey on a hoagie roll with bacon, banana peppers, no lettuce. I have NEVER ordered a hoagie and had to ask for lettuce. When I called I was told to come back and they would fix it, as I was on my way out the door I got a call back saying they made it the way I ask for it, and an argument over what the menu says.. I used to go there for a hoagie cause it was near by, will NEVER go back. Staff was very adamant that I needed to ask for veggies on my hoagie, also told me their green peppers were not for their hoagie, as they came from a can. I have never been treated like I was today, if they would have offered to fix it and make it right my whole opinion would have been different, now I paid for something I cant even eat, even paid extra for green peppers (apparently banana peppers,...

We had a very negative experience ordering a large order online and received little help or concern when we called in to inquire on why our order was changed drastically with no notification. It wasn't even remotely what we ordered and we didn't find out until we got home and opened the bags. I called and was told to call doordash. I did call and complained to doordash and received a partial refund, but none of this was doordash's fault. I also wrote a review here and on Yelp and received a full refund from Mileto's, so I've raised my review from 1 star to 3 stars. I'm sorry to say I still highly doubt I'll return because the staff were horribly rude and the food was sub-par, but I do appreciate the owners making things right in the long run, and so I'm changing my review from...